Develop Reference

How to store resource file with same name but different extensions in android

I am working on one static custom Android Media Player Application where i have many media files stored in raw folder.
Where as some files have same name but different extensions, here android is giving me
res\raw\then.mp4:0: error: Resource entry then is already defined.
res\raw\then.mp3:0: Originally defined here..
Can anybody please suggest me something on this?
Also there are few media files with java keywords like if, else, return, switch, case,class, else, final, long, new, this,true... where android is giving me error of invalid symbol.
Please suggest me solution for that also.
Thanks in advance...

As #blackbelt said, it's not possible, I'll just add that you can instead put your files in the assets directory instead of res.
You will not be able to use them like R.id.file, but you will get more flexibility.

simply you can't. Raw is build at compile-time inside R.java, and the name key must follow the java convention for naming. Since
if, else, return, switch, case,class, else, final, long, new,
this,true
are reserved keywords you can not use them.
Edit: R.java would look lie:
public static final class raw {
public static final int if=0x70000;

what R.java file actually does and how

I have been working on a simple android tutorial and while browsing through the project folders I found this R.java file in gen folder...
When I opened it seemed to me as a mess...
first R itself is a class.
it had multiple Inner classes defined within eg drawable,id,layout,etc.
and that inner classes had lots of variables declared as below which were assigned with hex values
public static final int addr=0x7f080003;
...
...
and much more
R is auto generated and acts as some pointer for other files
Questions for R.java
what it is basically for
how it works
why
values are in hex
what role did it performs while the actual application is running

"Acts as some pointer to other files" is actually absolutely correct, now the question is which files it points to how it is done.
What does it contain?
R file contains IDs for all the resources in the res folder of your project and also some additional IDs that you define on your own (in the layouts, for example). The IDs are needed for the Android resource management system to retrieve the files from the APK. Each ID is basically a number which corresponds to some resource in the resource management system.
The file itself is needed so you can access or reference the resource from code by giving the ID of the resource to the resource manager. Say, if you want to set the view in the activity, you call
setContentView(R.layout.main);
main in the R file contains the number which is understood by the Android resource management system as the layout file which is called main.
Why is it better than just plain file names?
It's harder to make a mistake with the generated fields. If you write the field name incorrectly, your program won't compile and you will know that there's an error immediately. If you write an incorrect string, however, the application won't fail until it is launched.
If you want to read more on this topic, you should check the Android documentation, especially the Accessing Resources part.

This holds your resource ids. So when you do something like
TextView tv = (TextView) findViewById(R.id.mytextview);
it looks up your id here for that View, layout, etc... This way the app has an easy way to look up your ids while you can use easy to remember names. Anytime you create a resource it automatically creates an id for it and stores it here. That's why you never want to try and edit this file yourself.

One way to think about how valuable R.java is, imagine a world without it. Its amazing how android brings the xml and java world together to help avoid coding the UI manually completely. With legacy java building UI using the java language was a pain. Invaluable.
With Android you can not only build your UI using only xml, but also see it while you build it. Invaluable.
Every element in the xml can be referenced in the java code WITHOUT writing a single line of code to parse the xml :). Just R.id.nameOfElement. Invaluable.
Rapid development is beautifully done in android. Imagine if iPhone would have 5000 screens to fit that one piece of code, they would crumble on their XCode. Google has done a wonderful job with just R.java. Invaluable.

Cannot override library's xml resource with png resource in application?

I have an Android library MyLib containing everything I need for my app (targeting Android 2.2). This library has an XML resource:
drawable/main_background.xml
In my Application MyApp project I reference MyLib. Here I want to override specific resources (i.e. branding). So I added a background image in MyApp:
drawable/main_background.png
Eclipse keeps giving me this error:
[com.mycom.mylib.myapp] res\drawable\main_background.xml:0: error: Resource entry main_background is already defined.
[com.mycom.mylib.myapp] res\drawable\main_background.png:0: Originally defined here.
How can I override the resource in the library project?

You cannot simply override resource ID (it's the resource ID you are overriding, not the actual file) with a file with different extension in Android SDK. However, you can do the trick by putting in your project xml file with the same name (main_background.xml) and fill it in a proper way to display your new file (main_background.png), which you need to rename earlier. All syntax you need is descibed here:
http://developer.android.com/guide/topics/resources/drawable-resource.html
, in your case it could be simply (assuming you put this in your non-library project as main_background.xml, and you have your new png as main_background_new.png):
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
<bitmap
xmlns:android="http://schemas.android.com/apk/res/android"
android:src="#drawable/main_background_new" />
With above solution, you could refer to #drawable/main_background from your project and it should use your file included with that project, instead of a library one.

[com.mycom.mylib.myapp] res\drawable\main_background.xml:0: error: Resource entry main_background is already defined.
[com.mycom.mylib.myapp] res\drawable\main_background.png:0: Originally defined here.
I don't believe you can have the same file name even with different extensions. Try naming the png something else.
Now, i've not used overriding, So this seems odd as you'd expect this to be how you override the asset. However i think you've either got the two assets in your lib named the same. And that in your project it might be ok to have an asset with the same name. I would however check that its ok to have different types. XML is different than png, and if you access the asset from code you could get type errors.
Let me clarify the above point. I understand that a library project can have an item with the same Resource ID as an item in your application.
However the error above suggests that both main_background.png and main_background.xml are in the same project ([com.mycom.mylib.myapp]) which i don't believe is correct.
Further reading
This page describes the various types of project including the library project http://developer.android.com/tools/projects/index.html
Now i don't know where i got the impression from but having looked again it simply doesn't state anywhere that you can override a resource by using the same resource name. God knows why i thought that was a feature.
So no, the same rule applies as far as i can tell, that resources have to be named uniquely even across library projects, otherwise the generated resource ids will conflict. (The error your getting)
What is explained is how resource conflicts are managed.
Resource conflicts Since the tools merge the resources of a library
project with those of a dependent application project, a given
resource ID might be defined in both projects. In this case, the tools
select the resource from the application, or the library with highest
priority, and discard the other resource. As you develop your
applications, be aware that common resource IDs are likely to be
defined in more than one project and will be merged, with the resource
from the application or highest-priority library taking precedence.
The system will use the resource with the highest priority, discarding everything else. Whats odd, is that you would think that a compile error wouldn't occur as the compiler should be discarding the resource. This makes me believe that the original poster had the similarly named assets in the same project, and not across the lib and project.
I haven't read anywhere that this is actually an intended feature. Got any links to say otherwise? (comment them)

So one 'solution' to this problem, which I do not consider to be an answer is the following:
Define an XML document in the library in question (we'll call it bunny.xml), and have it refer to another xml of a similar name (bunny_drawn.xml) with the actual content to be displayed.
Then, in the target project, override bunny.xml with another and use it to refer to an image with a different name instead - bunny_image.png
This does not however solve the problem, firstly because we aren't technically overriding a png with an xml (although the effect is somewhat close to that). Secondly because one of the key features of overriding resources is they are overridden, i.e. they are NOT compiled into the APK:
the tools ensure that the resource declared in the application gets
priority and that the resource in the library project is not compiled
into the application .apk
But the bunny_drawn.xml will still be compiled in! We can sort-of overcome the second point, by not only defining the image to be replaced in the target APP, but also replacing the old target bunny_drawn.xml with a blank xml. (or, as Fenix pointed out, you can have the contents of bunny_drawn.xml inside bunny.xml in the first case - the fact still remains that the resource ID can't be replaced...)
So my final conclusion is that this need to be submitted as a bug in the Developer Tools.

what does the "#+android:id/title" mean?

In normal, we should use #+id/ to define an id and use #id to reference an id. Today I found #+android:id/title in apps/settings/res/layout/preferenc_progress.xml.
How to understand it and how to use it?

It is used for resources that are shipped with the SDK.
You can take a look at them by browsing to
[PATH TO ANDROID SDK]/platforms/android-[VERSION]/data/res
By using the android in android.R.whatever you just specify the R file to look up. For more information you should read Accessing Platform Resources.

That belongs to the app preferences activity screen definition.
title and summary are standard Android fields of a TextView preference item.

I think it does the same thing. It's just a more formal way of saying it by specifying where the namespace is.

I've never met this way of giving id, but in theory this means adding new id title to android package. So you'll be able to use it in your code like android.R.id.title. But I'm not sure resource compiler will really create any id in android package. I think it can be used only with predefined ids. But I'll give you more precise answer later, when I'll be able to check it.
EDIT: I've checked it and found some differences. Firstly, if you define Android's id using #+android:id/some_id, which is already present in SDK, this id will not be defined in your R.java file. If it's not present in SDK, it will be defined in R.java, but with different kind of value. Secondly, if you'll try to convert id from its string representation to int value, Resources.getIdentifier() method will return 0 in case of #+android:id format.

This means it will create an id in your resource file.

Switch a whole application to alternative "styles.xml" files at run time?

my app has a styles.xml file with various visual constants defined.
I'd like my users to be able to switch the entire app to an alternative visual theme. I'd like to provide an alternative styles2.xml file and switch at runtime (via the Settings).
Is this possible, and how? I suspect the style names' appearance in the generated R class does not bode well.
If it's not possible, what's my next best option?

Not sure if anyone is still interested but I have found a possible solution. A bit hackish but gets the desired result.
Basically I set up my 2 style files in separate country code directories:
res/values-mcc199/style.xml
res/values-mcc198/style.xml
Then in my activity I use the following to change which is referenced:
Configuration config = new Configuration();
config.mcc = 199;
getBaseContext().getResources().updateConfiguration(config,null);
I've only done some basic testing so far but it appears to work. Obviously if you are already using country code to decide your layouts then this will interfere. I think there may be problems as well if the phone gets an event about a country change.

Actually, after some reading of the doc, it seems that this can be done. Look here.
As it is mentionned :
To create a set of styles, save an XML
file in the res/values/ directory of
your project. The name of the XML file
is arbitrary, but it must use the .xml
extension and be saved in the
res/values/ folder.
Now, if this is logical and I didn't read the doc wrongly, you can create as many styles as you want, reference them in themes.xml with #style/... (if you want to apply it to a whole activity or application) and then, just call
setTheme(R.id.yourtheme)
I think this should work. Have a go at it and tell us?

It's not an exact answer; in my blog post here:
http://blog.blundell-apps.com/switching-android-configurations-using-constants-and-ant/
I switch out a java class at build time using Ant, there is nothing to stop you switching out an XML file, as it compiles after the switch. To amend the tutorial you'd just have to change the path's of the file your templating.
Also mirrored on GitHub: https://github.com/blundell/BuildChoiceTut