According to the "Application Fundamentals" article, section "component lifecycle", onResume() is always called when a View becomes active, independent of the previous state.
In the Notepad tutorial, Exercise 3, I have found something confusing in NoteEdit.java:
There is a call to populateFields() in onCreate() as well as in onResume().
Wouldn't it be enough (or even better) to have it only in onResume() ?
In such a small example, it will not do any harm if populateFields() is performed twice, but in a bigger App, things can be different ...
Thanks and Regards,
Markus N.
From a look at Notepad3, I would say you are correct. There doesn't seem to be any reason for them to call populateFields() in both onCreate() and onResume(). onResume is sufficient.
I can see where you need it in both places, if application pauses then you would need it in onResume and if your process gets killed or user navigates back to activity then you will need it in onCreate especially if you are doing some pre-processing.
Per the documentation....for onResume() they recommend using it for lightweight calls unlike in onCreate():
"The foreground lifetime of an activity happens between a call to onResume() until a corresponding call to onPause(). During this time the activity is in front of all other activities and interacting with the user. An activity can frequently go between the resumed and paused states -- for example when the device goes to sleep, when an activity result is delivered, when a new intent is delivered -- so the code in these methods should be fairly lightweight. "
The Notepad app may want a variable declared if the method was already hit by onCreate not to redo in onResume().
Related
Hi I have gone though activity lifecyle on many threads, but I could not find what we should do in onStart, onResume, onPause method of the activity.
In the onStart() method, you add code that's relevant at the beginning of the activity.
Let's say, you have an app that reads the temperature of the device's battery. You'll want to have an initial value, so as to show the user.
So in the onStart(), you'd add code that goes ahead and fetches the information you'd need, and displays it for the user, before your timer (for example) goes and reads the information a minute later.
The onPause() method is called before the application goes in to the background.
To stay with our example, in the onPause() method, you'd save the last recorded temperature to the device; so you can show a comparison when the user next opens the app.
The onResume() method is called when the application is brought back to the foreground (i.e.: you've gone to the task manager, and tapped on your app to show it again).
Again, staying with the going example; in the onResume() method, you'd go ahead, read your saved data, load fresh data, and show a comparison of the two in the application.
Then, when your timer ticks next, only fresh data will be shown.
Your question is a bit vague, so answer might not be super specific..
I would say there are no strict "rules" around what we should do in corresponding activity lifecycle methods.
In fact, you can do nothing there (just make sure you call super method if you decided to override those). I.e. your custom activity might not even override these methods - it will work just fine.
onStart, onResume and onPause methods are just hints to you about activity lifecycle change, so you can react accordingly, i.e. start/stop specific to your activity operations at the appropriate time.
For instance, when onResume is called it means that activity became fully visible to the user, so you might want to start some animation (if necessary)
Again, you are not obligated to put any code in there.
Usually most of the operations are performed within oncreate and onresume.
However for your info let me brief it out,
Onstart- this is called after Oncreate, once activity is visible to the user, if you want to perform some operations before the visibility do it in Oncreate, because most of codes should be operated before user views the activity.
OnResume-Be cautious on Onresume is it is quite tricky it will be called whenever you activity is brought to foreground.
Onpause-Called before Onresume, codes wont be executed here, so strictly avoid adding codes in Onpause instead add inside Onresume.
Hope it helps,
I try to make Notification which must work only when Application UI isn't visible.
I tried to store preference which was written in onStart() and onStop() of my Activity. But sometimes, it's not working because another application became visible without MyActivity.onStop() being called.
What other method I can use for a Service to determine, if MyApplication is visible now? Or, maybe MyActivity?
If you already have code to keep track of the state of your app's UI, you can probably get it to work simply by putting the code in onPause() and onResume(), instead of onStart() and onStop().
It is possible for the UI not to be visible, or partially hidden, even before onStop() gets called ... as you found out.
Take a look at the Android Activity lifecycle diagram here:
http://developer.android.com/images/activity_lifecycle.png
and note the description:
The foreground lifetime of an activity happens between a call to
onResume() until a corresponding call to onPause(). During this time
the activity is in front of all other activities and interacting with
the user. An activity can frequently go between the resumed and paused
states -- for example when the device goes to sleep, when an activity
result is delivered, when a new intent is delivered -- so the code in
these methods should be fairly lightweight.
Read more about this in another question here.
This may be a bit of a stupid question but when is the best part of the Android life cycle to implement each step? The flow of my game is as follows:
Before onCreate: Data that is stored in a JSON file is parsed into String Lists when the game starts
onCreate: Basic UI is generated
onStart/onResume: Game starts: item selected at random from the lists, user selects corresponding item to proceed
If the user is correct, another item is selected from the lists. Occurs 10 times
After 10 items, game ends and score is displayed to user
Would this be considered good practice? I'm a bit confused about the life cycle steps
This might help with understanding the lifecycle of an Android app more. The following is quoted from that site:
As mentioned in the previous section, the lifecycle of an activity has 4 states and 3
lifetime periods. If you want to monitor and adding your own code
logics to an activity, you can use the following 7 basic callback
methods provided by the android.app.Activity class:
onCreate() - Called when the activity is first created. This is where
you should do all of your normal static set up: create views, bind
data to lists, etc. This method also provides you with a Bundle
containing the activity's previously frozen state, if there was one.
onCreate() is always followed by onStart().
onRestart() - Called after
your activity has been stopped and prior to it being started again.
onRestart() is always followed by onStart().
onStart() - Called when
the activity is becoming visible to the user. onStart() is followed by
onResume() if the activity comes to the foreground, or onStop() if it
becomes hidden.
onResume() - Called when the activity will start
interacting with the user. At this point your activity is at the top
of the activity stack, with user input going to it. onResume() is
always followed by onPause().
onPause() - Called when the system is
about to start resuming a previous activity. This is typically used to
commit unsaved changes to persistent data, stop animations and other
things that may be consuming CPU, etc. Implementations of this method
must be very quick because the next activity will not be resumed until
this method returns. onPause() is followed by either onResume() if the
activity returns back to the front, or onStop() if it becomes
invisible to the user.
onStop() - Called when the activity is no
longer visible to the user, because another activity has been resumed
and is covering this one. This may happen either because a new
activity is being started, an existing one is being brought in front
of this one, or this one is being destroyed. onStop() is followed by
either onRestart() if this activity is coming back to interact with
the user, or onDestroy() if this activity is going away.
onDestroy() -
The final call you receive before your activity is destroyed. This can
happen either because the activity is finishing (someone called
finish() on it, or because the system is temporarily destroying this
instance of the activity to save space. You can distinguish between
these two scenarios with the isFinishing() method.
How are you pre-loading data before onCreate? You got no Context object to work with app filesystem before your onCreate called. Here is documentation for Activity lifecycle, as you can see, onCreate is the first method where you can run your code.
I suggest to put data loading in other thread, for example AsyncTask.
So:
Generate basic UI
Start data pre-loading NOT IN MAIN THREAD
Update UI after data loaded
I've read several posts that describe the difference between onStart() and onResume(): onStart() is called when the activity becomes visible, onResume() is called when the activity is ready for interaction from the user. fine.
I've always just added code to onPause() and onResume(), and never bothered with onStart() and onStop().
Can anyone give some concrete examples of what you might do in onStart(), vs. onResume()? Same goes for onStop() and onPause(), how is onStop() useful? I must be missing something fundamental here.
onStop() will (for example) be called when you leave the activity for some other activity (edit: almost. see commonswares comment about dialog themed activities).
For example if you use startActivity() in activity A to start activity B. When you press back in activity B you will return to activity A and onStart will be called.
This differs from some of the reasons onPause might be called without onStop being called. If for example the screen times out or you press the standy button onPause will be called, but probably not onStop (depending on memory available and whatnot), so it is a "lighter pause". onStop will be probably be called eventually even in this case, but not immediately.
Ok, but what's the use
Often there is no specific use, but there might be. Since your activities will keep its memory state on the stack even after you start some other activity, that stack will increase with the number of activities started (height of the stack).
This can lead to large memory usage in some applications. After a while the framework will kick in and kill some activities on the stack, but this is rather blunt and will probably mean a lot of states to be retained when returning.
So an example use for onStart/onStop is if you want to release some state when leaving an activity for another and recreate it when you get back.
I have used it to set listadapters to null, empty image caches and similar (in very specific applications). If you want to free the memory used by visible views in a listadapter you can recreate it in onstart and let the views be picked up by the gc. This will increase the likelyhood that the rest of the memory state of the activity will live on.
Some resources can be deemed good enough to save while the activity instance is alive and some only when it is on the front of the stack. It is up to you to decide what is best in your application and the granularity of create/start/resume gives you that.
onStart() works after onCreate() ended its task.
It's a good place to put a broadcastReceiver or initialize some state about the UI that should display consistently anytime the user comes back to this activity.
onResume() works when you come back to your Intent or Activity by pressing the back button. So onPause will be called every time a different activity comes to the foreground.
i think that your question is pretty explained here on the doc : read about the Activity Life Cycle
The Activity Lifecycle is giving me headaches.
The documentation at http://developer.android.com/reference/android/app/Activity.html is so darn ambiguous when it describes the concept of visibility, that I can't figure out when onStop() is called vs onPause().
Compare the following two statements from the documentation:
(taken from right beneath the lifecycle diagram)
The onStart() and onStop() methods can be called multiple times, as
the activity becomes visible and hidden to the user.
vs
(further down in the blue table with the "killable" columns)
onPause() Called when the system is about to start resuming a previous activity.
What I'd understand from the first quote, is that onStop() is called on activity A when A is "hidden". "Hidden" I'd guess is referring to when another activity B has been resumed and is completely covering actvity A.
But the second quote then states that onPause() is called when another activity is about to start resuming. Wouldn't that completely hide activity A as well? Both cases seem to imply that that activity A becomes "hidden", no? According to my likely faulty interpretation, onPause() and onStop() are called in identical situations.
The documentation also seems to differ between being hidden (onStop() gets called) and being partial visibility (onPause() gets called). But when is an activity still partially visible? Do they mean literally? Or can an activity still be deemed "partially visible" when it has started up a new activity (activity calls startActivityForResult and starts a date picker activity) that covers the entire screen? Surely the activity is not going get onStop invoked? Its supposed to receive a result any moment!
So I'm trying to figure out what I'm not getting.
I understand that a call to onPause is guaranteed. That would be when activity A loses focus (device enters sleep mode, screenlock, etc), a different activity B takes the foreground (where activity B may or may not have been initiated by activity A).
But at which point is the onStop() invoked on activity A?
Is it matter of how many activities have been piled ontop of activity A on the activity stack? Are there two different definitions of "visiblity" at play?
Sorry about the wall of text, but I'm really frustrated :S
So the question stands: Precisely in which situations is an activity deemed "hidden" such that onStop() is called on it?
EDIT:
I inserted Toast notifications in each onX method, and discovered some additional weirdness:
Pressing the Home button will always call onStop(). But starting up the application won't call onRestart(). Instead it calls onCreate(). This seems strange to me, but ok...
When the "USB Mass Storage" activity is started on top of the main activity, onStop() is called. And when exiting the usb storage activity, returning to the main activity, onRestart() is called, instead of onCreate().
When the device goes into Sleep mode and is waken up, the activity only goes through the onPause() and onResume() cycle.
The last point was expected (although I can't get it to fit in the lifecycle diagram). But whats up with 1. and 2. ?
In the first point, I was expecting a call to onRestart() when starting the activity again. Why did it deallocate the activity and call onCreate() instead?
And take a look at point nr 2:
According to the documentation: when "another activity comes in front of the activity", onPaused() should be called. Isn't that what happened when the USB Storage activity came up? It didn't call onPause(), it went through the onStop() - OnRestart() cycle! Obviously, the documentation doesn't consider that a case where "another activity comes in front of the activity". So what really happened?
Ok, I think I've got this now.
1.
The key to the first point was this link:
http://code.google.com/p/android/issues/detail?id=2373
Its a bug. Theres some code in the link that has completely solved the problem with new root activity instances being created, instead of just restarting the last active activity (before the home button was pressed).
I put the code at the top of the onCreate method, just below the super.onCreate call:
if (!isTaskRoot()) {
final Intent intent = getIntent();
final String intentAction = intent.getAction();
if (intent.hasCategory(Intent.CATEGORY_LAUNCHER) &&
intentAction != null && intentAction.equals(Intent.ACTION_MAIN)) {
finish(); return;
}
}
Note that I added the return statement after finish so the rest of the onCreate method doesn't run in the case that the bug is detected.
2.& 3.
The key to the second and third points was these two links:
http://answers.oreilly.com/topic/2692-android-programming-understanding-the-activity-life-cycle/
How to make Activity, not covering full screen
It turns out that "visibility" really is literally! So when the documentation says "another activity comes in front of the activity", the activity behind the bumped activity is still partially visible. This means that the Android Activity manager must check whether the bumped Activity is a full-screen activity or not: If it is, onStop() is called on the previous activity. If not, then onPaused() is called on the previous activity instead.
This trivially explains why the USB Storage manager caused the onStop() to be called.
This also means that when device goes into sleep mode, the Activity Manager considers it a non-fullscreen activity, even though technically the main activity is completely hidden behind it.
(See the second link on how to make non-fullscreen activities )
Interestingly, the pull-down window (with the notifications) doesn't call onPause() (nor does it call onStop()), even though it would have made sense as a non-fullscreen activity. This must be some kind of exception that I'll be investigating on my own.
This also means that the onStop()-onRestart() cycle is probably more common than the onPause()-onResume() cycle (although both must still be accounted for), since activities probably more often than not are full-screen activities (personally, I thought the documentation indicated the opposite: that onPause-onResume was more commmon, but maybe thats just me).
Additionally, this must mean that when the main activity starts a new fullscreen activity for a result, the main activity will be first stopped and later restarted when the result-retrieveing activity is done.
So the only question now is how to best deal with a paused activity (meaning, it is covered by a non-fullscreen activity) that gets deallocated (although this case would be rare). What challenges may there be?
But thats outside the scope of this question.
Finally tracked this down: you can detect the status bar pulldown using onWindowFocusChanged()
how to use OnWindowFocusChanged method