I am coding an android application that gets the user position every 5 minutes, stores it in the database and sends it to a server.
I have read many ways of doing it, I was going to do the following:
User starts the application
The main UI activity starts a service.
The service runs in background and keeps turning on and off the gps, and creating new
threads that will save to database,and send the data to the server.
But I have seen that it can be done with a "Remote service" (http://developer.android.com/resources/samples/ApiDemos/src/com/example/android/apis/app/RemoteService.html) or with an AlarmManager that schedules starting this service every 5 minutes.
The service will need to be running always: it is important that after every interval (5 minutes), it is executed.
I think I need some clarity here.
Thank you for your help,
I am coding an android application that gets the user position every 5 minutes, stores it in the database and sends it to a server.
Please allow the user to choose the location provider. Not everybody has GPS on their device. Not everybody has GPS enabled. And, not everybody will want the power hit of GPS being turned on every five minutes.
Please allow the user to choose the polling period, including "never poll -- I'll refresh the information manually from the activity". Also, please honor the background data setting (deprecated as of ICS).
I think I need some clarity here.
If the polling is supposed to go on even if the activity is not in the foreground, use AlarmManager. However, most recipes for using AlarmManager will have the real work (in your case, GPS fix and network I/O) be handled by an IntentService. This will not work in your case, because GPS is asynchronous -- you cannot just get a fix whenever you feel like it. It will take a long time, possibly forever, to get a fix, so you have to deal with the delay and eventually timing out the operation. Writing a Service to do this is possible, but tricky, particularly if you are aiming to collect this information even if the device falls asleep.
If, however, the polling is only supposed to go on while the activity is in the foreground and the device is on, I wouldn't bother with a Service at all. Just have the activity use postDelayed() to set up an every-five-minutes scheduled bit of code to run, then have it do the work.
Related
I'm trying to develop an Android app that among other things, uses location services to get user location and sends it to a remote server. The user can turn this feature on and off according to his own will, but as long as it's turned on, it will get user location periodically (maybe each 30 seconds, don't know it for sure yet). Also, while it is turned on, it must keep tracking the user even if the application is closed.
So far I've considered 2 options:
Option 1 - Use Service, call startForeground to make sure Android don't kill it (the sticky notification is not an issue to me) and use a LocationListener with the said interval, but this seems rather inefficient as the service would be doing nothing most of the time, I mean, the listener would be called each 30 seconds, send the location to the server and the service itself would spend the next 29.9 seconds or whatever just waiting for the next location.
Option 2 - Doing some research, I've seen some approaches using AlarmManager to trigger some background service (like seen in this post), but I'm concerned that using alarms that often (every 30 seconds) might not be good for the battery and system general performance (in a code snippet in this page of Android's Developer guide there's a comment saying that "hopefully your alarm will have a frequency lower than 30 MINUTES").
Maybe there's another option that I still haven't thought about, or maybe there's a way to put the service from option 1 to sleep for some time or something like that. Bottom line, I'm looking for the approach that doesn't impacts on performance, consumes the minimum amount of battery and has the least chance of being killed by Android.
Any help and/or suggestions are welcome.
I need to keep rough track of a users position, but not really in real time. It's sufficient to handle the location updates when the app is started. However, I still need to know where the user was when the app wasn't running.
Is there a way to get the location history in an app?
I don't really want to have a service just polling last known location all the time since that would be a waste of battery power.
However, I still need to know where the user was when the app wasn't running.
That is not possible.
I don't really want to have a service just polling last known location all the time since that would be a waste of battery power.
Then eliminate your requirement for location history. You only get the locations that you request.
Rough Track can mean you get location of the user (lastKnown or Fresh) after every n-hours. Doing this will not require a service, simply a recurring alarm and receiver will do. In the onReceive method of receiver, you can manage a stack of locations in your app.
You will have to reset the alarm though when the device re-boots. I guess this is an add-on, rest should work fine.
you can not get current location without running your app...
the second way is to make background service ..wich you don't wan't to make...
The other way is to run background service using Alarammanager whenever you want after getting location you can stop the service...like you can make call every hour or 2 times per day...
this scenario is very common according to the Android documentation but still I don't find a straight solution neither there nor anywhere on the net.
So I have a service that should do something like this:
Register a LocationListener to receive the user location
Once the LocationListener is called - stop listening for a 5 minutes
After 5 minutes start listening again and loop from 1
This is the recommended way to save battery power while listening for the user location.
As a service I have a major problem with step 3.
The only way I found to "wait" for 5 minutes is to schedule a java.util.Timer to execute a TimerTask in 5 minutes and this TimerTask should register the LocationListneres again.
However this does not work because of:
java.lang.RuntimeException: Can't create handler inside thread that has not called Looper.prepare()
Which is also expected because requestLocationUpdates should be called from a "main" thread.
Ok .. nice... but I don't have a Main thread. I don't have an activity. From the TimerTask I can't send an intent to the service to register my listeners back.
How can I ask my own service to register my listeners again?
This is the recommended way to save battery power while listening for the user location.
Really? The only way that's a good pattern is if you are using AlarmManager for the five-minute delay, so the device falls asleep in between location checks.
The only way I found to "wait" for 5 minutes is to schedule a java.util.Timer to execute a TimerTask in 5 minutes and this TimerTask should register the LocationListneres again.
And that would be a horrible use of battery, because it would mean you would need to keep the device powered on constantly, not allowing it to go to sleep.
I don't have a Main thread
Yes, you do. All processes have a main application thread. onCreate(), onStartCommand(), etc. of a service are called on the main application thread.
I don't have an activity.
Then you better write one, as your app will not work on Android 3.1+ without it. Your app will not run until a user launches one of your activities on Android 3.1+.
How can I ask my own service to register my listeners again?
What you are trying to accomplish is a rather complex problem. Not only do you need to arrange for the device to fall asleep and wake back up again, but you also need to deal with lots of edge cases (e.g., what if no location is available, because the device is in airplane mode or is underground or something?).
I wrote LocationPoller to handle your use case, and another developer forked it to create a more feature-rich implementation.
Whether you use one of these directly or simply examine their implementation, they should be useful to help you understand how to solve this problem. All of the details, though, are well beyond the scope of a StackOverflow answer -- it would take several pages in a book to explain it all.
You can specify the parameter in requeestLocationUpdates() to make it run after a certain time.
I've created an android app that is so far working quite well. It contains a local service which is responsible for getting the users location every couple of minutes and relaying that via UDP to a collection server which is in turned displayed on a web application map.
The app needs to be constantly running unless the user explicitly signs out of the application. Currently, it seems the OS is shutting down the service and restarting it as needed. I can see this because normally it would report its location consistently every 2 minutes. Instead, there are gaps in these intervals.
So I'm looking for some advice on how I can write a service which (at the battery's expense unfortunately) can stay running always and pool the location service just enough to send accurate fixes at a 2 minute interval.
I have a well working code base so far, so if demonstrating where I currently am with code would help, don't hesitate to ask.
Thanks in advance to those that lend a hand.
Your best bet is to use the AlarmManager to wake up every two minutes, do some processing and quickly go back to sleep.
If you think you're hardcore, you could even use a wake lock, but that will keep the phone's CPU turned on persistently without mercy. You don't want that.
I believe it's because of some power saving option or whatever but I cant debug it since it only fails when it's on battery
I have a service that checks on a webpage every 60 seconds
I use an asyncTask in the service to do this
and I make it Thread.thisThread.sleep(60000); before checking
am I doing something wrong? could the sleep function cause the server to be stopped by android?
I have a service that checks on a webpage every 60 seconds I use an asyncTask in the service to do this and I make it Thread.thisThread.sleep(60000); before checking
Please don't do that.
First, make the period configurable, including a "don't do this, ever" option. Users really do not like it when developers write apps whose primary purpose appears to be to use up a ton of battery life. Keeping the device awake and polling a Web server every minute is going to use up a ton of battery life. It is behavior like this that is causing users to run to every task killer they can find.
Second, particularly for periods greater than a minute or so, please use AlarmManager and a [WakefulIntentService][1]. Schedule the AlarmManager to invoke your application at the user-chosen period (ideally via setInexactRepeating()). Have the WakefulIntentService poll your Web page. If you follow the documented WakefulIntentService recipe, the device will stay awake long enough for you to get your data, then will fall back asleep. Your service will not remain in memory all of the time. You get your functionality, and the user gets better device performance.