Whenever I use setRequestedOrientation(int) it behaves differently from when I declare the orientation in my Manifest.xml.
(this is expected)
I read that (from docs):
If the activity is currently in the foreground or otherwise impacting the screen orientation, the screen will immediately be changed (possibly causing the activity to be restarted)
Practically this means that whenever an app is started, while the device has an orientation that is NOT the orientation that will be set with setRequestedOrientation(int), the activity will be created twice (once 'normally' and once to reflect requested orientation).
As of now it is not worthwhile to make my activites 100% config-change-proof, what I would like is a way to set the requested orientation, in code, without having to create my activities twice. Is there a way?
(Preferably without using hackish workaround such as setting the 'orientation' flag in configChanges)
EDIT:
Accepted answer is right, it simply isn't logical (doesn't make sense). For new readers, what I did was add a stub-activity (mainly empty activity that doesn't do much). All it does is use getRequestedOrientation() when it differs from what I want it to be, I will call setRequestedOrientation(int), otherwise start the activity I want and in its onCreate also call the setRequestedOrientation(int) to keep it in requested orientation.
No, that doesn't make sense. If you set the orientation programmatically, the Activity is already running before you can do anything to change the duplicate creation for each orientation.
I have stumbled on a problem, that, when the screen turns off while being in LANDSCAPE orientation, certain devices "rotate" the app back to PORTRAIT position (because the lockscreen is PORTRAIT only or something like that). I did a little research before posting this, and most popular work-around is to modify app's configuration change process to prevent activity being recreated after the configuration has changed.
But disabling activity recreation is not a solution for me, because my app supports both orientations with sepparate layout's etc.
So i would like to find out, is it possible to disable the configuration change only in special cases (Screen turned off and orientation is landscape)? Or is the right way to override onConfigurationChanged() then manually manage activity recreation inside that function (i guess simply setting different layout resources when orientation is changed simply wont cut it)?
Or is the right way to override onConfigurationChanged() then manually manage activity recreation inside that function?
Yes to an extent.
You cannot set the configChanges attribute programmatically. I guess it's to do with the way an Activity is created. They're created from the XML first and then the overridden methods in your activity implementation are invoked. There's nothing in the API that lets you change the configChanges attribute.
Now in your case it doesn't sound like you need to. If you support both orientations, then if the user locks the device and it rotates back why does it matter? From a UX perspective we know it's in portrait mode again. So should your app when it opens back up.
I have used both approaches:
Let the activity be destroyed on rotation
Don't let the activity be destroyed on rotation
My approach almost everytime is to catch the rotation event and if needed call the setContentView and add some components again. If not, just let it rotate and the layouts are designed to adapt.
So far I only have seen advantages on letting it be destroyed on screens with very complex construction that are very dynamic, and whenever I rotate and not destroy show some flickering when re-building the screen.
The overhead of having to pass the state with onSaveInstance, onRestoreInstace is sometimes very error prone, and somehow time consuming.
Am I missing something?
UPDATE:
I'm not doing any kind of if "Orientation.XPTO == ..." on my code. This is the logic of each of the 2 approaches (the code is reused):
When destroying
onCreate -> DrawUI() setContentView and add views -> fill() add content
When not destroyed:
onCreate -> DrawUI() setContentView and add views -> fill() add content
onRotation -> DrawUI() setContentView and add views -> fill() add content
When calling setContentView after rotation it will pick the right layout for the device orientation (Check this answer by Google's Reto Meier https://stackoverflow.com/a/456918/327011 )
And the DrawUI and fill would have to have the logic for both the portrait and landscape layouts as the activity can be created on each of the two orientations to begin with.
Am I missing something?
Yes. You are assuming that your alternative is somehow less error prone.
By not going through the destroy-and-recreate cycle, you have to ensure that you are handling changing every resource for every possible configuration change.
Don't let the activity be destroyed on rotation
Unless you are using android:screenOrientation to force your activity into a single orientation (e.g., landscape), you cannot only handle rotation-related configuration changes. You need to handle all configuration changes. Otherwise, as soon as the user drops their device into a dock, removes it from a dock, changes language from Settings, attaches or detaches a keyboard, changes the global font scaling, etc., your app will break.
This, in turn, means that on every configuration change, you need to:
update your UI for your potentially new string resources
adjust or reload your layouts (and by "adjust" that includes changing any drawables, animations, menus, etc.)
anything else tied to your resources (e.g., array lists in your PreferenceFragment)
The problem is that you are going to forget something. For example, you will miss changing a string associated with an action bar item, so now most of your UI is in Spanish and that action bar item is in English. The sorts of things you are going to forget will be less obvious (how often do you test your Spanish translation?).
Your activity is destroyed to give you the opportunity to reconfigure yourself for the new orientation.
From the developer.android.com:
When the screen changes orientation, the system destroys and recreates
the foreground activity because the screen configuration has changed
and your activity might need to load alternative resources (such as
the layout).
For example, in landscape mode you may require a completely different layout, or may want to load in graphics that would not appear stretched. The best way of doing this is allowing the activity to be created again, which will allow the linking to the layout file to change to a more orientation-friendly layout.
See http://developer.android.com/training/basics/activity-lifecycle/recreating.html for more info and how to deal with the orientation change
If you want to disable the recreation you can add
android:configChanges="orientation"
to your Activity element in AndroidManifest.xml. This way your Activity will not be reloaded.
onSaveInstance and onRestoreInstace should only be used for passing through session information, for example the current text in a TextField, and nothing generic that can just be loaded in again after onCreate.
If you, restarting the Activity, requires recovering large sets of data, re-establishing a network connection, or perform other intensive operations then using the onSaveInstanceState() could potentially cause your noted symptoms:
A poor user experience (i.e. "show some flickering")
Require consumption of a lot of memory
onSaveInstanceState() callbacks are not designed to carry large objects.
To retain an object during a runtime configuration change:
Override the onRetainNonConfigurationInstance() method to return the object you would like to retain.
When your activity is created again, call getLastNonConfigurationInstance() to recover your object.
However:
While you can return any object, you should never pass an object that is tied to the Activity, such as a Drawable, an Adapter, a View or any other object that's associated with a Context. If you do, it will leak all the views and resources of the original activity instance. (Leaking resources means that your application maintains a hold on them and they cannot be garbage-collected, so lots of memory can be lost.)
Source
Unless you are able to pass the Object(s) smoothly I personally think it is more advantageous to handle the configuration change yourself, meaning not to destroy.
If you have a target API of 13 or higher: You must include screenSize in your configChanges. Starting with API 13 the screen size also changes on orientation change and you'll need to account for this. Prior to 13 your Activity would handle this itself.
android:configChanges="orientation|screenSize"
Some time it is useful when you are using different layouts for (Landscape / Portrait ). and using different type of views for example ListView in portrait and GridView in landscape.
I guess you are not considering the standard way of creating the android layouts. Please correct me If I'm wrong. Are you using two res folders with -port,-land separately to tell android system to choose in runtime to load the different assets and layout on the basis of orientation.
This example can give you a clue to manage layouts in different orientations.
Here is the android stanard document. Please check with "land" and "port".
Hope this will help you.
Is onDestroy() guaranteed to be called when I rotate the screen?
I heard that one can define onConfigurationChanged() to change this default behavior. What would usually be written in that method? And what are the other ways to change the default behavior of rotation?
Is onDestroy() guaranteed to be called when I rotate the screen?
Yes
onConfigurationChanged() will be called for any configuration change you want to handle yourself (you declare those configurations under configChanges in your manifest). I think the best would be to avoid that altogether.
You can disable rotation in the manifest by setting Orientation for your activity such as 'portrait' or 'landsacpe'
Normally if the orientation can change you will want to save and then restore some of your data using onSaveInstanceState and then restoring the data back in onCreate
I want to be able to change the layout when a device is re-orientated to landscape or portrait. For speed and resource purposes (plus other issues applicable to my app) I do NOT want my app to be destroyed and restarted. I have several objects which I wish to retain between orientation changes as there is no benefit from destroying and re-creating them! I simply just want to change the position of some buttons and TextViews so that they suit the current orientation. Easy right?
Well no it isn't. To achieve the above I included in the app Manifest the configChange option for orientation change. Then I've implemented the onConfigurationChanged() where I determine and apply the appropriate layout. Simple yes?
But now take the textview I have in my layout. How on earth, using this particular method of responding to orientation changes, do I put the same text in the previous textview to the new textview? No instance data is passed to onConfigurationChanged() method. Also for some of the buttons, they could be disabled or enabled... I need to know this after orienatation change.
If I let Android destroy and restart my activity it's first going to create unnecessary work. All I want is to just move a few buttons and textviews.. NOT restart the whole app. That's just ludicrous!
Can anyone help me achieve what need?
An easy way to maintain configuration-independent data is to make use of onRetainNonConfigurationInstance() and its companion method getLastNonConfigurationInstance(). Just return an object that contains all the data that you want to reuse when your activity is recreated.
In Honeycomb, or if you are using the Android compatibility package, you can just call Fragment.setRetainInstance(true) instead. See the docs.