I am building an application for Android. It will interface with some C++ libraries using Android NDK through JNI. There are also some libraries that are written in Python that I want to call from my Android application (e.g. NTLK). How can I do that?
Please note that SL4A (Scripting Layer for Android) is something different. It allows you to build an application using a scripting language like Python, Lua etc. In my case the application will be in Java but will need to call code that has been written in Python. Is this possible in an elegant way?
I recommend putting the NLP code into web services on a Linux server and calling those from android.
This is quite straight forward in a framework like django.
Related
I am currently planning the development of a multiplatform app, and I am not sure wich way to do it fits my requirements best, since all possibilties I could think of failed to satisfy me.
First I want to write an app for android, which should feel like a normal typical android app. So I want to use the standard actionbar and android design look and feel in my other gui elements. After finishing the android app I am planning on developing an ios app, which should have a different design, so i am going to redevelop the gui for this anyway.
But I don´t want to rewrite the other code wich represents the intelligence of the app, independent from the gui. I came up with the following possibilities:
1. Java GUI With native library
Here I abstract all the code of my app in a C++ library (since as far as I know ios supports the usage of c++ libraries too) and develop the gui android typically in java. The library would than have a function to start and would inform the gui about every change via callback functions.
Pro
I can reuse all the code that would be the same on both platforms. I just would implement the gui seperately
The design of the android gui is straightforward as I want it to be. It looks like typical android because it is typical android.
Cons
I dislike the usage of JNI very much. Especially the signature and names of the callback functions (calling java functions from c++) are not checked at compile time and require a lot of manual work. If I rename a function and forget to rework the native part I only notice this mistake at runtime.
2. Build the GUI on the native side
Here I had difficulties finding out what is possible, especially for 2.2
2.1 Use Qt
I have only a few first step experiences with Qt in general but as far as I understood i would have the following pros and cons:
Pro
Reuse most parts of the code for ios and Android. I would than redesign the gui for each platform to make them feel natural. I can´t evaluate how much qt may even assists me at doing that
Cons
I have to copy the android gui by using other qt widgets. This is more effort and I don´t know if one can replicate the android gui elements (like the actionbar) so that the user wouldn´t notice it.
2.2 Using the android framework from the native side
I dont know if this is possible at all, I wasn´t able to find this information. Can I use the class "NativeActivity" and use the android framework to build the gui and use e.g. the actionbar? If this is possible somehow it would have the pros from 1. and maybe wouldn´t have it cons?
Do you have any feedback to my ideas or maybe even new approaches I didn´t think of? How do other multiplatform apps like WhatsApp solve this problem? Do they have redundant code for each platform?
Thank you,
Tobi
I would say that it depends very much on your application requirements. By my opinion, a better solution is to develop a separate application for each platform using recommended SDK's for that platform, and implement in native C++ only the time consuming data processing algorithms.
Application runtime on mobile platforms is not so straightforward as on desktop platforms. You should take into account background and foreground processing, specific application life cycling, accessing system resources such as network, file system, etc. And all these issues do differ on iOS and Android.
Regarding possibilities that you listed.
Qt/QML is ok only in case two requirements are met:
1.1 Your application is a foregroud application without any background operations.
1.2 You purchase a commercial Qt license because only commercial Qt can be submitted to Apple iTunes app store (even GPL apps are under
question).
Using NDK Native Activities on Android with cross-platform C/C++ backend. Android NDK API offers much less API then Android Java SDK, so a lot of things you will have to implement or wrap manually. It is a hard road.
Mixing Java code and C/C++ using JNI gives you more of Android SDK API. But you should remember that an Android activity's life cycle is not somewhat that you're used to deal with when developing on C/C++.
Approach that we are using
We've been developing an application with a huge amount of cross platform functionality that should work on Windows/Linux/Mac OSx/Android/iOS. We're using the approach as follows.
Cross-platform core is written in pure C++.
We have adaptors to GUI interface for each platform.
On desktop we use Qt as it reaches all desktop platforms with minor adapting to each platform.
On iOS the GUI is built using iOS SDK with Objective-C and C++ core is linked as a Framework. Still, we had to patch our core in some way for iOS background requirements and so.
On Android we wrap our C++ core in a background process and build all the GUI using only Android Java SDK. Foreground GUI activities interact with the core via local sockets, so we don't need to bother with activities life cycling in our C++ core. But the adaptor is a litle bit complicated.
Nevertheless, both mobile platforms often require workarounds and adaptations in C++ core which add a number of #ifdef'ed branches in code for each platform.
I'm writing Android app.
The problem is that it should execute some calculations and library for this is written in Python.
What is the best way to invoke Python from Android/Java?
I heard about Kivy and even managed to run application, but python code returns latex formulae, that can't be rendered within Kivy app.
You can probably render LaTeX in Kivy fairly easily using a png exporter (such as presumably exists for web export tools, and modes like emacs' preview mode).
If you need to run python as part of a java app, probably a practical way to do it is to use kivy's python-for-android tools with your own java frontend, invoking the python interpreter via JNI. This would require some thinking and experimentation but should be possible. There are also other projects for building python for android, which might be able to do the same things.
I have my own C++ library with source code. It contains functions like this: CreateDvice, FillDevice, CloseDevice and etc. There is no dependency to any third-party libraries.
There is requirement to create application for mobile platform:
Blackberry
iPhone
Android
The application has to use logic provided by this library.
Is there chance to use existing library in mobile application or at least some of them?
Or does it require to re-implement library code for each platform?
For iOS (iPhone/iPad) you can directly compile your library and use it from a regular iOS app written in Objective-C++ and/or C++.
For Android you can directly compile your library using the NDK, then either write your app in Java and call your library via JNI, or write the whole app in C++ using the NDK.
I believe you are out of luck on Blackberry, for this platform you'll need to rewrite your library in Java, as neither apps or libs can be written in C++.
Edit: See my other answer for a completely different approach that may work for you.
Blackberry:
It's technically possible to have ASM on BlackBerry (or Android, iPhone, etc.) but 3rd-party developers are often not allowed (or not able in the case of BlackBerry) to do so.
iPhone:
Absolutely. You can statically link a C++ library. Of course it will have to be compiled with the right instruction set. There are a host of examples out there on how to do this. Translate - you will need the code.
Android:
Absolutely. There is a good book on this by Mark Murphy. Introductory material here:
http://www.androidguys.com/2009/10/14/android-beyond-java-part-one/
Your question is unclear. Do you need a cross-platform library/engine to create a mobile application?
If it is so, Cocos2D would be the best choice. Originally it's a game engine, but it is suitable for applications too. And it supports all the platforms written above.
Instead of compiling your C++ library on each target device that you intend to support, you could opt for creating a service that packs your library. You can install this library on a host you have control, then from each platform the only thing you need to do is invoke this service.
I'm not sure if this thing makes sense for the kind of library that you have, but this would be a way to maintain a single version of your library, and you'll have a guaranteed same behavior on all devices.
Good luck.
Android is not natively Java, it's natively C++. And iOS is also natively C++. So why not just leave the C++ code untouched and drop RIM's current platform (since they are switching to BBX which does support C++ as well).
For Blackberry you can use the C++/Qt Cascades; for iOS you can use C/C++ & Objective-C (a superset of C) and Android can use the C++ NDK. You can use Java on all platforms as long as the Java apps are standalone and the JRE is pre-packaged with the app (iOS). You can interface with C/C++ libs using JNI
If you want to use a Java library on all platforms, that would work.
Android and Blackberry are natively Java.
You can use a tool called XMLVM to cross-compile your Java library to Objective C for use on iOS.
http://xmlvm.org/overview/
It is not 100% perfect, but pretty darn close. We use it extensively to port common Java library code to iOS. Port the C++ library to Java and you are good to go.
There are some cool python scripts out there and I was wondering what is involved in running one within an Android device? Is this possible? I don't want to call out to a server. Thanks
It is possible, although with limitations.
The Scripting Layer for Android provides and interface for script languages to expose a great deal of Android's internals.
You will need a specific built of python though, that you can get here.
Some libraries are also being simplified and shrunk to be available on Android. For example pyGame (pretty much the standard for 2D games on python) has recently released this.
Take a look at SL4A.
I am developing an application on Android and this application will be transported on IOS.
My question is simple: how can I make a transportable code? Are there rules to simplify the copy of the code in another language?
Have you seen java2objc - a tool to convert Java code to ObjC code.
You can also try something like MonoTouch (for iPhone) and MonoDroid (for Android), which allows you to develop in .NET.
iOS applications are mostly written in Objective-C. Android applications are mostly written in Java. You can't copy the code into another language. You must port your Android Java code manually to Objective-C/Cocoa-touch. If your Android application is web based, you can simply re-use the same HTML in a webview. iOS and Android apps work differently and users expect a different experience, so understanding the differences will help you in creating easily ported code.