I am trying to build a soundboard app that plays a sound whenever you tap on a custom view. In order to organize my UI, I used a layout file.
When I extended View, I found that when I tried to inflate my layout, it wouldn't work.
//Didn't work
View v = View.inflate(context, R.layout.sound_view_layout, null);
When I extended LinearLayout, however, it did work.
//Worked
View v = View.inflate(context, R.layout.sound_view_layout, this);
My question is,
how come I needed to extend a Layout class in order for the program to work, and what are the benefits of doing so?
Well you can only inflate a layout. If you want to just create a View, use new CustomView(context).
Ignoring that- the main reason to extend a layout is if you want to add children to it programmatically, or if its a collection of views already (for example you may want to create a view CaptionedPhoto that has an image on top of text. One way to do this would be to make CaptionedPhoto extend LinearLayout and hold an image view and a text view).
What is the difference between a View and a ViewGroup in Android programming?
View
View objects are the basic building blocks of User Interface(UI) elements in Android.
View is a simple rectangle box which responds to the user's actions.
Examples are EditText, Button, CheckBox etc..
View refers to the android.view.View class, which is the base class of all UI classes.
ViewGroup
ViewGroup is the invisible container. It holds View and ViewGroup
For example, LinearLayout is the ViewGroup that contains Button(View), and other Layouts also.
ViewGroup is the base class for Layouts.
Below image is the answer. Don't take it too complex.
A ViewGroup is a special view that can contain other views (called children.) The view group is the base class for layouts and views containers. This class also defines the ViewGroup.LayoutParams class which serves as the base class for layouts parameters.
View class represents the basic building block for user interface components. A View occupies a rectangular area on the screen and is
responsible for drawing and event handling. View is the base class
for widgets, which are used to create interactive UI components
(buttons, text fields, etc.).
Example : ViewGroup (LinearLayout), View (TextView)
Reference
View is a basic building block of UI (User Interface) in android. A view is a small rectangular box which responds to user inputs. Eg: EditText, Button, CheckBox, etc..
ViewGroup is a invisible container of other views (child views) and other viewgroups. Eg: LinearLayout is a viewgroup which can contain other views in it.
ViewGroup is a special kind of view which is extended from View as its base class. ViewGroup is the base class for layouts.
as name states View is singular and the group of Views is the ViewGroup.
more info:
http://www.herongyang.com/Android/View-ViewGroup-Layout-and-Widget.html
ViewGroup is itself a View that works as a container for other views. It extends the functionality of View class in order to provide efficient ways to layout the child views.
For example, LinearLayout is a ViewGroup that lets you define the orientation in which you want child views to be laid, that's all you need to do and LinearLayout will take care of the rest.
Viewgroup inherits properties of views and does more with other views and viewgroup.
See the Android API: http://developer.android.com/reference/android/view/ViewGroup.html
in ViewGroup you can add some other Views as child. ViewGroup is the base class for layouts and view containers.
View is the SuperClass of All component like TextView, EditText, ListView, etc..
while ViewGroup is Collection of Views(TextView, EditText, ListView, etc..), somewhat like container.
A View object is a component of the user interface (UI) like a button or a text box, and it's also called widget.
A ViewGroup object is a layout, that is, a container of other ViewGroup objects (layouts) and View objects (widgets). It's possible to have a layout inside another layout. It's called nested layout but it can increase the time needed to draw the user interface.
The user interface for an app is built using a hierarchy of ViewGroup and View objects. In Android Studio it is possible to use the Component Tree window to visualise this hierarchy.
The Layout Editor in Android Studio can be used to drag and drop View objects (widgets) in the layout. It simplifies the creation of a layout.
In simple words View is the UI element which we interact with when we use an app,like button,edit text and image etc.View is the child class of Android.view.View
While View group is the container which contains all these views inside it in addition to several othe viewgroups like linear or Frame Layout etc. Example if we design & take the root element as Linear layout now our main layout is linear layout inside it we can take another view group (i.e another Linear layout) & many other views like buttons or textview etc.
A ViewGroup describes the layout of the Views in its group. The two basic examples of ViewGroups are LinearLayout and RelativeLayout. Breaking LinearLayout even further, you can have either Vertical LinearLayout or Horizontal LinearLayout. If you choose Vertical LinearLayout, your Views will stack vertically on your screen. The two most basic examples of Views are TextView and Button. Thus, if you have a ViewGroup of Vertical LinearLayout, your Views (e.g. TextViews and Buttons) would line up vertically down your screen.
When the other posters show nested ViewGroups, what they mean is, for example, one of the rows in my Vertical LinearLayout might actually, at the lower level, be several items arranged horizontally. In that case, I'd have a Horizontal LinearLayout as one of the children of my top level Vertical LinearLayout.
Example of Nested ViewGroups:
Parent ViewGroup = Vertical LinearLayout
Row1: TextView1
Row2: Button1
Row3: Image TextView2 Button2 <-- Horizontal Linear nested in Vertical Linear
Row4: TextView3
Row5: Button3
So I really have two related questions on ViewGroups:
Is a LinearLayout and instance of ViewGroup? Meaning, can I call getChildAt(index) when using a LinearLayout?
Can I detect when a ViewGroup child is at the "top" of the screen (right below the action bar) after scrolling? For example, when the 3rd child is scrolled to the top
I'm working on an app that utilizes Parallax Scrolling and I'm using an open source library that has a custom View with a LinearLayout as a child and 4 TextViews as the LinearLayouts children. In their custom View class they are calling getChildAt but I can't seem to find documentation on that related to LinearLayouts so I wanted to check. And essentially I want to check if one of these TextViews are at the top of the screen. Any clairfication would be much appreciated
question 1 { Is a LinearLayout and instance of ViewGroup? Meaning, can I call getChildAt(index) when using a LinearLayout? }
answer = yes... A ViewGroup is a special view that can contain other views (called children.) The view group is the base class for layouts and views containers .. so your linear layout is a view because it extends view, and if it contains other sub views called children then it's a viewgroup.. viewgroup extends view.. Meaning YES you can call getChildAt(index) when using linear layout..
question 2 { Can I detect when a ViewGroup child is at the "top" of the screen (right below the action bar)? }.
answer YES , you can check the Z order of the children in a viewgroup(a view containing other sub views) to know its position, so probably your first child is the child below the actionbar, that's if your viewgroup (that is the linear layout) is the view content of your activity - which is always the case right? - yea..
if you want a documentation on getChildAt and viewgroups in general then look here ..
hope it helps.. let me know anything that's arising..
I have a class that extends view and in it I am creating my customized view. At certain step I want add a layout created here in tis question to my customized view.
I also referred to some examples but but they seem have the same problem reversed, they have a layout and want to add a customized layout to it.
How can I add a layout to my customized view?
Maybe your class should extends ViewGroup instead of View.
With a ViewGroup you will be able to use addView() to add inflated layout in your custom view.
For more info on addView take a look at Android doc
how do you place a view inside of a view in android xml? I have come from a web development background so the closest example I can think of is placing div's inside of div's, something like this for example
You can't place Views inside Views (i.e. ImageView inside an ImageView).
You can place Views inside ViewGroups (i.e. an ImageView inside a LinearLayout).
Please check here for more info: http://developer.android.com/guide/topics/ui/index.html and here: http://developer.android.com/resources/tutorials/views/index.html
Hope this helps!
You can't place views inside another view.
A View occupies a rectangular area on the screen and is responsible for drawing and event handling. View is the base class for widgets, which are used to create interactive UI components (buttons, text fields, etc.). The ViewGroup subclass is the base class for layouts, which are invisible containers that hold other Views (or other ViewGroups) and define their layout properties
some viewgroups are
AbsoluteLayout, AdapterView, FragmentBreadCrumbs, FrameLayout, GridLayout, LinearLayout, RelativeLayout, SlidingDrawer, Toolbar, TvView, CardView, etc