How many strings is too many for an android app - android

I am creating a language learning app and I have a section in the app that will be dependent on fairly large amounts of text. about 800 words per activity, spread out over different text views. I am planning to store the paragraphs / sentences in the strings resource. which will more o less equate to 100 strings per activty and about 10 activties.
In total the R.jar file will have between 1000 -1500 seperate string id's.Is this a lot or too much for an app. Will this make my app really slow or is it normal practice for a text based app?
I know that I could store the data in sqlite database but prepoulating the database then filtering results and placing each string into its corresponding view programatically would be a real pain in the neck and I think would be even slower. and I would prefer to declare the string in the xml layout straight from the resource.

Android creates static references for all strings you place in Resources and application will load all instances in memory when app is launched.
Its unnecessary object creation.
You should go for creating a db for all words and use when they are required.

Related

What is the best way to save a string-array in SQLite on Android?

One string size is about 200 bytes,
and it stores 10~20 size in a daily array.
(Store 10~20 strings of 200bytes, as array type)
I have found a way to convert an array to a string
and store it in SQLite.
However, I do not know it's a good idea
because the size of the string is large.
1.
If large arrays of strings,
is it a good idea to store arrays as a string?
2.
or is there a better way?
I would like advice. Thank you.
You're actually placing your concern onto the wrong part of your database design.
For SQLite, the maximum length of a String is 1 billion bytes, so your worries about your 10-20 strings of 200 bytes each actually isn't considered that large.
There's really no harm in storing your array as a single long String in your database. Especially when it's nowhere close to the maximum limit of a String.
Your database query time won't become longer due to your String being long. The real concern here is the processing you'll be doing on that String to turn it back into an Array. Typically, if the String is extremely long, the real performance hit is when you're flattening the array into a String and when you're transforming that String back into an Array.
However, typically, this is something you'll show a loading indicator for to your users.
For storing an Array into a database, there's really only two ways to do so:
Flatten array into a single String and store the String as TEXT
Create a table meant to store the individual elements of the string, and include a column for a Foreign Key that allows you to associate those rows with the same array. Then you'll store each element of your String arrays as a row in this table.
Depending on what you need, one design is better than the other.
For example, you would normally prefer the second implementation if your app requires you to constantly edit individual elements of an array.
For such an example, it wouldn't make much sense to use the first solution, because this means every time you want to edit the contents of an array, you'll be fetching back the complete array in it's entirety. This is impractical when you only want to fetch or edit a particular portion of that String.
Therefore, in such an example, it is much more practical to store the individual elements of the arrays into individual rows of a Table meant for this type of data. You'll be querying only the row you want and updating only the row you want.
So to answer your questions, there's really only two ways to store your String array as a TEXT type in your SQLite database. Both ways work and the real concern is to consider which solution fits your needs best.
If your app only requires you to store and fetch the array in it's entirety each time, then the single String method might be more preferable.
But if your app requires you to work with individual elements of your array, then using the table method would be more convenient.

String Array in SharedPreferences

I need to work with a persistent String Array (n Rows, 1 column).
* On first running the app, the String Array needs to be created empty.
* On subsequent app executions the Array will be populated from a File and the contents need to be available throughout the rest of the app.
* As the app is executed, the Array needs to be able to 'grow' in row count
* As the app is executed, the Array rows need to be able to grow in length
* The user will have the option to Clear the Array of previous entries.
* At the end, the String Array contents will be written back to a File.
I find a lot of references to Putting and Getting from an existing SharedPreferences String[] but, in the newness of my Android development, I am struggling with how to proceed.
EDIT Follows...
The data itself suggests using an Array
Example:
MAIN ST. F55 63 KY08:57 12142015--------KY11:24 12142015345TMH KY13:57 12142015
MAIN ST. F56 WYE123 IN08:57 12142015--------KY11:24 12142015--------KY13:57 12142015
1ST ST. F57 --------KY08:57 12142015--------KY11:24 12142015789FPF KY13:57 12142015
1ST ST. F58 456FPF KY08:57 12142015998FPF KY11:24 12142015--------KY13:57 12142015
1ST ST. F59 789TTM KY08:57 12142015--------KY11:24 121420151234DG KY13:57 12142015
I first need to have this data in a File
Then in one GUI I check for the existence of the file.
If one exists, fine
If none exists, I create one.
Then, in subsequent GUI's, I must check for the existence of parameters
If they do not already exist, add them to the existing data lines.
If they already exist, notify the user
And so on and on.
Then when all of the current 'pass' data has been collected via multiple, separate GUI's, I have to write out the whole data-set into the file.
My reason for thinking that I need a SharedPreference approach is the need to find and check data from GUI to GUI as the user progresses through the app.
If that 'belief' is wrong, I am open to better approach suggestions.
EDIT 2 follows....
On further study of web references, I am beginning to think that perhaps the best approach for this data and how the data needs to change might be to use a SQLite approach. Any ideas about this?
Any assistance/suggestions you might have would be greatly appreciated.
i would discourage you from using sharedpreferences for anything else than preferences. means things that change rarely - really rarely and are really lightweight. do not put much data in there. less is better. the data structures underlying sharedpreferences are not a database.
another note. it is not a string list, but it would be a string set. sets are not necessarily ordered, nor do they necessarily keep their order. means - it is not rows. its a collection of strings that can come back in any fun order (usually there is some, but that depends on the implementation which i do not know)
now you could go and make your own list, your own data structure, save it into a string and read it out, use json to do exactly that or something similar, or better - use a database, which would exactly do that.
http://developer.android.com/training/basics/data-storage/databases.html
explains it, but as you'll see its something that might take some time.
now dont get me wrong, but i have to warn you about the following approach. it is valid, but has many problems and is far from thread safe. it will not be a problem as long as you only open it from the ui thread and do not keep anything in memory to cache - if you do it will create lots of problems.
your problem of adding a line and clearing can be solved by using a file. just a simple file
look here
http://developer.android.com/training/basics/data-storage/files.html#WriteInternalStorage
the change is to append when writing:
openFileOutput("filename", Context.MODE_APPEND);
see the context mode? now you can basically just write one line and append every time.
if you wanna clear the file, just deleteFile("filename")
this is as said not threadsafe, but can be a viable option if used carefully.
Please follow this step to achieve what you want with sharedPreference
create the class Parent for SharePreference
Create your empty Array
Convert Your empty array to String and put it on SharedPreference
to call your empty array from sharedPreference
Call your sharedPreference using your key
Convert the String to array
You get your array from the sharePreference
Hope it helps, and maybe this link will help you :
http://www.androidhive.info/2012/08/android-session-management-using-shared-preferences/
You can use my open-source library called prefser, which solves this problem and uses SharedPreferences and Gson under the hood. It's basically wrapper for default Android mechanism.
You can use it in the following way:
Prefser prefser = new Prefser(context); // create Prefser object
prefser.put("key", Arrays.asList("one", "two", "three")); // save array of Strings
String[] value = prefser.get("key", String[].class, new String[]{}); // read array of Strings
For more information check repository of the project, tests and README.md file.
Link: https://github.com/pwittchen/prefser
Please note, SharedPreferences have some limitations and shouldn't be used for storing large amount of data. If you expect a lot of data, consider using SQLite database or another type of database (e.g. with NoSQL or similar approach if you strive for simplicity).
OK, based on the data, how it needs to be manipulated and the pros and cons of using a SharedPreferences approach, I have decided to go with a SQLite approach.
With that approach I should be able to readily check:
* if the necessary table exists (if not create it)
* if the necessary Field1 + Field2 exists (if not create a new record)
* and I will be able to modify the record's Field3 contents as needed
Then when the user's actions are complete I can convert the SQLite table 'records' into strings and write them out as a File and then either DROP or PURGE the associated SQLite table (until needed next time).
I sincerely appreciate all of your suggestions.
Thank you.

How to represent user application settings in Android

Iam working on an android application and have trouble making a decision for the architecture saving application data.
Following case:
In the app the user has the possibility to create new general objects and give them properties he want. To support this, i want to give them a list with favorites before creating the input form, for example a car. It has color, weight, speed, horsepower etc.
So the user can choose a often picked object (for example the car) and will get the appropriate fields for the form he has to fill (color, weigth ...).
This list should be smart. The more you pick an item, the higher it appears in the list. And this presets have to be editable in preferences.
And thats the point. Should I implement my idea with the preferences framework from android (save it to xml as different preferences types and simply load due preferencebuilder) or should i create own xml objects and save it to self created user file location?
My second question: if i use the preference framework method .... is this made good for dynamically add entries at runtime? the ressources are in the res folder, but what if there are individual user entries? will they also be saved in the program folder or is there a special user data folder where the files (maybe encrypted) are in?
Thank you
Storing such complex data in SharedPreferences is tricky. What I mean is assuming user created 4 objects and each has 8 properties. You would store 4*8 values in sharedprefs and map them too.
What can be done is maintain an array list of objects created by user. Consecutive to that list maintain counter array list and keep swapping both lists internally as per number of times user has clicked the object. example:
List Name List Counter
ObjA 5
ObjB 3
ObjC 1
ObjD 1
Store these two lists in Shared Prefs.
Now, for the object's properties part (2 possibility arises) :
Maintain a mySQL DB and a table for each object's name. You can store values of each column in it IF you need to store every instance created of the object by user. (every time user clicks the object just show him/her the column names of table and store the values entered)
Example :
ObjA Table :
Color speed horsepower rpm
________________________________
red 20mph 100 3000
black 80mph 500 8000
Consecutively, if you don't want to store every instance value, you can make another sharedPrefs with object as key and an Arraylist of properties as value.

How to store xml data into sqlite database

I have a xml format data which is came from server. Now i want to store it into database and it should load on button click. How should i do this?
enter code here
<qst_code> 7 </qst_code>
<qst_prg_code> 1 </qst_prg_code>
<qst_mod_code> 2 </qst_mod_code>
<qst_Question>What is not true about left dominant cardiology circulation? </qst_Question>
<qst_opt1>It is seen in 20% of the population</qst_opt1>
<qst_opt2>Left circumflex artery supplies the Posterior descending artery</qst_opt2>
<qst_opt3>Left circumflex artery terminates as obtuse marginal branch</qst_opt3>
<qst_opt4>Left circumflex artery may originate from right coronary sinus</qst_opt4>
<qst_opt01>1</qst_opt01>
<qst_opt02>1</qst_opt02>
<qst_opt03>1</qst_opt03>
<qst_opt04>1</qst_opt04>
<qst_CorctOpt>1</qst_CorctOpt>
<qst_Marks>10</qst_Marks>
<qst_company_code>1</qst_company_code>
<user_code>1</user_code>
One option is to store it as a string if the data is not too large, else break it into a schema that maps to sqlite and recreate it while loading.
If your XML data is large, I would rather change the data exchange type to json. XML parsing and then insert is a very expensive operation and is time-consuming.
Some issues which you will face with XML parsing and insert.
a. XML parsing is memory intensive and so you heap size will grow, you need to keep an eye on this as this might cause crash.
b. Inserts in SQLite DB will take around ~100ms per tuple (row), so you can calculate the time it will required to pump in thousands of rows of data.
If you data is not too large don't bother about using SQLite.

Can large String Arrays freeze my program?

I recently created a program that gets medi-large amounts of xml data and converts it into arrays of Strings, then displays the data.
The program works great, but it freezes when it is making the arrays (for around 16 seconds depending on the size).
Is there any way I can optimize my program (Alternatives to string arrays etc.)
3 optimizations that should help:
Threading
If the program freezes it most likely means that you're not using a separate thread to process the large XML file. This means that your app has to wait until this task finishes to respond again.
Instead, create a new thread to process the XML and notify the main thread via a Handler when it's done, or use AsyncTask. This is explained in more detail here.
Data storage
Additionally, a local SQLite database might be more appropriate to store large amounts of data, specially if you don't have to show it all at once. This can be achieved with cursors that are provided by the platform.
Configuration changes
Finally, make sure that your data doesn't have to be reconstructed when a configuration change occurs (such as an orientation change). A persistent SQLite database can help with that, and also these methods.
You can use SAX to process the stream of XML, rather than trying to parse the whole file and generating a DOM in memory.
If you find that you really are using too much memory, and you have a reason to keep the string in memory rather than caching them on disk, there are certainly ways you can reduce the memory requirements. It's a sad fact that Java strings use a lot of space. They require two objects (the string itself and an underlying char array) and use two bytes per char. If your data is mostly 7-bit ASCII, you may be better of leaving it as a UTF-8 encoded byte stream, using 1 byte per character in the typical case.
A very effective scheme is to maintain an array of 32k byte buffers, and append the UTF-8 representation of each new string onto the first empty space in one of those arrays. Your reference to the string becomes a simple integer: PTR = (buffer index * 32k) + (buffer offset). "PTR/32k" yields the index of the desired byte buffer, and "PTR % 32k" yields the location within the buffer. Use either an initial length byte or a null terminator to keep track of how long the string is. When you need to access one of the strings, don't allocate a new String object: unpack it into a mutable StringBuilder or work directly with the UTF-8 byte representation.
The above approach is obviously a lot more work, but can save you between a factor of 2 and 6 in memory usage (depending on the length of your strings). However, you should beware of premature optimization. If your problem is with the processing time to parse your input, or is somewhere else in your program, you could find that you've done a lot of work to fix something that isn't your bottleneck and thus get no improvement at all.

Categories

Resources