I started programming Android-Apps a few weeks ago. First, many thanks to all the members of this forum. Numerous posts helped me solving my problems with my app. But now, I have a problem I cannot handle and I dont find an answer.
So, what is the problem:
In my app I want to display a kind of table. On my main testing device everything fits good. But when i tried the app on an AVD with a smaller screen i realized, that the text size (in dp) is to big and the system creates a second row to display all the letters. Therefore, I decided to create an own layout for the four different classes of screen sizes with four different text sizes.
According to http://developer.android.com/guide/practices/screens_support.html and http://developer.android.com/guide/topics/resources/providing-resources.html#BestMatch and many other posts on the internet the system choose the right layout automatically.
But I assert, that it doesnt. The system always load the default layout. I cannot understand why. When I delete the default order, it always load the small layout, even on my Galaxy Note 2. And on the AVD with the smallest screen, the app is closed with an error while starting. However, the normal layout runs on the smallest screen...
I even tried this to support the layout, but no success:
<supports-screens
android:smallScreens="true"
android:normalScreens="true"
android:largeScreens="true"
android:xlargeScreens="true"/>
Every xml-file has the same name. And th folders are named 'layout', 'layout-small', 'layout-large' and 'layout-xlarge'.
Can anyone help me? I guess, I just missed a little trick...
I don't think you want 'layout', 'layout-small', 'layout-large' and 'layout-xlarge'. While those do exist, they're sort of generic, and the behavior isn't as clearly defined. See this table:
http://developer.android.com/guide/practices/screens_support.html
You are using size, not density. Try these instead:`
ldpi Resources for low-density (ldpi) screens (~120dpi).
mdpi Resources for medium-density (mdpi) screens (~160dpi). (This is the baseline density.)
hdpi Resources for high-density (hdpi) screens (~240dpi).
xhdpi Resources for extra high-density (xhdpi) screens (~320dpi).
The resulting folders are layout, layout-ldpi, layout-hdpi, etc. This is how I've always done it and it works.
It might be more about density than size. Why don't you try instead of separating by size, to use ldpi, mdpi, hdpi, and xhdpi?
OK, I think this is the best solution...
http://www.vanteon.com/downloads/Scaling_Android_Apps_White_Paper.pdf
Related
hi I'm new in android developing and it's my first app.
I have made these folders in address : app\src\main\res for supporting multiple phone and tablet screens and put proper dimens.xml files in them.
values-ldpi
values-mdpi
values-hdpi
values-xhdpi
values-xxhdpi
values-xxxhdpi
values-sw600dp
values-sw768dp
values-sw800dp
first of all, are they complete or am I missing some screen sizes?
second, I've tested the app on several devices and it's working fine and has proper user interface in all phones but on the Galaxy Grand Prime which has a 5 inch 540 x 960 pixels display that means 220 dpi. this phone using hdpi dimens but UI is a bit messy.
The following pictures may make my point better :
Proper UI , as it is shown in other devices
VS
UI in galaxy grand prime 220 dpi display
as UI is completely OK in other devices, I thought I should make a specific dimens.xml file for that kind of dpi, so I made values-sw220dp. but after that other phones used this dimens instead of hdpi dimens and problem got worse because UI was fine in the galaxy phone and was not proper in other hdpi displays. and now I don't know what should I do.
can anyone help me in this issue?
at last sorry because of flaws in my english , as you can guess I'm not a native.
are they complete or i'm missing some screen sizes?
If you read the guides which I mentioned at the end of my answer you will find that there are very many possibilities of defining resources folders. I think nobody will want to implement all of them.
Usually you look at your app and then decide on maybe three or four screen sizes you want to support. I think "sw220dp" is important, if only to show a message that your app needs more space :-).
So there could well be three to five layout folders (sw220dp, sw320dp, maybe sw480dp, sw600dp, maybe sw820dp). If you need orientation-dependent layouts, then the number will be twice that much. (Why ? That's explained very well in the guides linked below)
You already know that there are different types of resources. Some of them do not depend on the screen resolution (e.g. layout files), some do (drawable resources).
So first of all you decide which screen sizes you want to support. Let's say they are "phone", "tablet" and "220dp". You create three layout files by the same name "my_activity.xml" and put them in three folders
for the really small window: res/layout-sw220dp
for the mobile phone: res/layout-sw320dp
for the tablet: res/layout-sw600dp
By the way, "sw" stands for smallest width which is the minimum length of the screen, no matter what the orientation is currently.
Now let's assume you have created three different layout files and all of them contain an ImageView like this:
<ImageView
android:layout_width="24dp"
android:layout_height="24dp"
android:src="#drawable/my_picture" />
This is where the screen resolution comes into play: 24dp is a size value in "density-independent pixels". It will be resolved depending on the screen resolution of the device. So you need different versions of my_picture.png, and for this you need different folders for drawables. They are named after the different categories for screen resolution so the runtime knows which png file to pick:
res/drawable/ldpi (although I read somewhere you can skip that because the pictures will be scaled down from hdpi nicely)
res/drawable (here go the resources for res/drawable-mdpi as well as every drawable resource for which resolution does not matter, e.g. drawables defined via xml files)
res/drawable-hdpi
res/drawable-xhdpi
res/drawable-xxhdpi
res/drawable-xxxhdpi
Helpful links:
Providing Resources
Supporting Multiple Screens
I have all of the dpi drawable directories (are xxhdpi and xxxhdpi even necessary?) consisting of nine-patch bitmaps, the drawable resource file in the drawable directory that retrieves all of the scaled bitmaps, and I set the backgrounds of the Buttons with the drawable resource file... Now, my problem is that I also created "scaled" layout directories in terms of size (small, normal, and etc.), in which I tried to manually change the dp of the buttons as follows:
Here's my xhdpi bitmap:
... But it appears like this on the Nexus 7 virtual emulator (7.0", 1200X1920: xhdpi) in the layout-large directory:
... And when I manually change the dp size to 200 of one of the buttons:
^^^ How do my directories look by the way? ... And why does the button appear like that? ^^^
All of that said, I just don't understand why we need density-based drawable directories (mdpi, hdpi, xhdpi, and etc.) as well as layout resource directories, when we could just simply modify the dp of images in each unique layout regarding the screen's size (small, normal, and etc.).
#dpark14 I basically already answered the question you asked in a your post from yesterday here: Is modifying the dp size as opposed to pixels recommended for various screen sizes?
Perhaps you should have edited your last question to include the code and images above so it could be consolidated.
As I said in my answer (and one of the other comments said):
It is entirely up to you if you want to change the layout width and height (in dp) of an imageButton. There is certainly nothing wrong with setting width and height of an imageButton or any UI element for that matter, in each unique layout resource file for various screens. Did you have specific code you wanted to get feedback about?
Now that you have included some images I can see some of what you have.
You should really take a look at this:
Android Studio drawable folders
And it would benefit you to read through the Android documentation again:
http://developer.android.com/guide/practices/screens_support.html
To summarize a few general ideas:
You don't need a default drawable folder, but you should have the following:
drawable-mdpi (medium) ~160dpi
drawable-hdpi (high) ~240dpi
drawable-xhdpi (extra-high) ~320dpi
drawable-xxhdpi (extra-extra-high) ~480dpi
drawable-xxxhdpi (extra-extra-extra-high) ~640dpi
As the Android documentation says in the link above:
Your application achieves "density independence" when it preserves the physical size (from the user's point of view) of user interface elements when displayed on screens with different densities.
Instead of:
If, for some reason (as it looks like you're having issues with) you've achieved density independence, but your image doesn't fit well, that's when you can start to step in with changes to w/h and res/layout
Also from my previous answer:
As you alluded to: you could create different res/dimens directories for various devices based on "minimums" e.g. w800dp/dimens.xml and then create elements in that specific dimens.xml e.g. values-w411/dimens.xml for width and height that correspond with your images that aren't fitting well when you test your app.
As a first step, perhaps you should try it out. Yes, this takes time, but try a stand-alone test separate from your app first. Just add one image (perhaps the one you are having issues with). See what happens when you load it into different Nexus devices in the emulator. Does the image achieve "density independence" i.e. preserves the physical size across devices? If it does, and there's an issue with its w/h in relation to the confines of a specific device, as I said in my previous answer and now here, create a dimens directory (within a values-... directory) specifically for the problem device and change the layout_width/layout_height for that specific image or view.
For more on specific device w/h: https://design.google.com/devices/
This question already has answers here:
Android screen size HDPI, LDPI, MDPI [duplicate]
(4 answers)
Closed 9 years ago.
I have to manage different screen sizes and different densities in my Android app.
I am not getting directory structure properly.
What I understand so far is there are four types of screen sizes:
small
normal
large
xlarge
and different densities as well:
ldpi
mdpi
hdpi
xhdpi
Now each device size (small , normal , large and xlarge) shall map against each density. Because every size can have different density, right?
If yes, then we can say small screen have all the density i.e ( ldpi , mdpi , hdpi , xhdpi)
same for normal, large and xlarge.
The point is how I'll manage them in my drawable directories.
Will there be four folders for small screen size with different size (drawable-small-ldpi, drawable-small-mdpi, drawable-small-hdpi, drawable-small-xhdpi)?
And same for other screen sizes as well.
If not then how I'll manage all the image in ( drawable-ldpi , drawable-mdpi , drawable-hdpi , drawable-xhdpi) folder because different screen size I'll have different size of images. Then how can a small device with different density and large device with a different size be manageable in same density folder.
Please don't give me reference of any Android document as I read all that stuff.
If any one can't get my point, then please let me know. I'm very confused.
When I have started development in Android, I was confused about same issue.But now I have figured it out and I'm doing pretty well.
Anyways, You are absolutely right.you can provide different images by 4 folders for each.i.e.: drawable-small-ldpi, drawable-small-mdpi, drawable-small-hdpi, drawable-small-xhdpi
But it is just waste of your time.because you don't need to worry this much about it.Android can scale up/scale down according to the device configuration.so just provide extra images for those devices only if you don't get desired outputs for them.
As far as I know, supporting multiple devices, you have to consider few general criteria in your mind.
Density qualifiers: ldpi,mdpi,hdpi,xhdpi,etc are generally used when you want to provide different resolution images.
Size qualifiers + Orientation qualifiers: small,normal,large,xlarge,sw600dp,normal-land,normal-port,etc are generally used when you want to provide different layout designs.
i.e.: single pane layout,multi-pane layout,different elements in layouts according to different screen sizes.
For reference: Download the example app from here and try to understand how it is being supported for multiple screens.
I hope it will be helpful !!
Here are official docs for you to read about the subject: Supporting Multiple Screens then Supporting Different Screen Sizes
Put your all image in all different folder that is drawable-hdpi, drawable-ldpi, drawable-mdpi, drawable-xhdpi and drawable-xxhdpi. android will take care of it.
What I always do is just put all my images in one folder (usually xhdpi). The Android system will scale them for you so you don't have to worry about what to put in what folder.
Heres what Android says about this:
Provide different bitmap drawables for different screen densities
By
default, Android scales your bitmap drawables (.png, .jpg, and .gif
files) and Nine-Patch drawables (.9.png files) so that they render at
the appropriate physical size on each device. For example, if your
application provides bitmap drawables only for the baseline, medium
screen density (mdpi), then the system scales them up when on a
high-density screen, and scales them down when on a low-density
screen. This scaling can cause artifacts in the bitmaps. To ensure
your bitmaps look their best, you should include alternative versions
at different resolutions for different screen densities. The
configuration qualifiers you can use for density-specific resources
are ldpi (low), mdpi (medium), hdpi (high), and xhdpi (extra high).
For example, bitmaps for high-density screens should go in
drawable-hdpi/.
You can find the documentation here:
https://developer.android.com/guide/practices/screens_support.html
Hope this helps
Last two questions stayed unanswered, I hope "third one's the charm" works :)
I want application that is HDPI use those drawables in folder "drawable-xhdpi" and LDPI devices those in "drawable-mdpi". So I don't have to duplicate same images. Is this possible?
Yes, Android scales drawables, selecting the drawable that will produce the best result. But not all scaling combinations work that well. Downscaling to MDPI can produce noticeably poor results. XHDPI to HDPI generally produces pretty good results. But given that the overwhelming majority of devices these days are HDPI, it's probably worthwhile to have HDPI resources. HDPI to XHDPI scaling is not terrible. Some 1280x720 devices uses XHDPI resource. These generally look ok. Google TV uses XHDPI as well. On a huge screen, scaling errors are visible.
LDPI devices are -- for all practical purposes -- non-existent now.
True that generating scaled resources is an enormous PITA. But, in my opinion, you really need to do MDPI and HDPI. And once you've got that unpleasant workflow down, it doesn't require a lot of extra work to generate XHDPI. For what it's worth, if your artwork is in vector format, the vast majority of resources don't need tweaking for specific resolutions. There doesn't seem to be any compelling need to pixel-align edges of square objects, for example. Usually it's only interior features in complex icons and artwork that benefit from some amount of pixel-pushing.
It's pretty clear that XHDPI is going to be come more and more common. Trust me, you don't want to go back and re-do all your artwork in XHDPI after the fact. My advice: if you intend to still be shipping your app a year from now, suck it up, and do the nasty as you go, while it's still relatively easy.
In my experience, if you place an image in just some of the drawable folders, but not all, the OS will choose the "best" image for the device that you are using, even if it is not exactly the perfect fit. For example, if you put an image called arrow.png ONLY in the drawable-hdpi folder, all devices will use that image for the arrow drawable, and scale it down or up appropriately, stretching or shrinking the image.
That being said, you should be able to accomplish what you want by simply putting your image in the right folders and allowing the devices to choose the correct one. For example, if you were trying to accomplish your task with only one image, arrow.png:
drawable-xhdpi/ -> arrow.png
drawable-hdpi/ -> empty
drawable-mdpi/ -> arrow.png
drawable-ldpi/ -> empty
drawable/ -> empty
If you use the app on an ldpi device, the device will use the mdpi image, as you wanted, because it is closest to the correct resolution. On the hdpi phone, it will use the xhdpi image, because it is again the closest to the correct resolution.
Yes. Android automatically downscales/upscales resources that it cannot find. If you were to only put resources in the XHDPI folder it would just work, Android would take care of resizing them to work in all the other densities.
We should add this code in MainActivity class and copy image to dhpi folder with ic_launcher, ic_launcher2, ic_launcher3 and ic_1 is image name, we can change size: width and height
int array_image[]={R.drawable.ic_launcher,
R.drawable.ic_launcher2,
R.drawable.ic_launcher3,
R.drawable.ic_1
}
I have a quick question: will it work when I put the same 57px x 57px icon to all drawable-ldpi, drawable-mdpi and drawable-hdpi folders. Will it run on all devices?
in other words if small icon will be visible on big screens or x-large screens.
It will work, but you really should not use size of 57x57 for any screen size - scaled down images will look as ugly as scaled up. Better avoid it.
Please read more here: http://developer.android.com/guide/practices/ui_guidelines/icon_design_launcher.html (yes, it is an official documentation).
Yes, it'll work. But it is good to have all icons. Because it'll be pixelat on large screens.
If you simple put icon in drawalbe folder (which is default folder) and you don't have any other folders like hdpi, mdpi, ldpi for all screen sizes. then it'll also be considered for all resolutions/sizes.
It will work. But it will not look well on some screen.