I have 2 activities which are using the same Android task - i.e. they will use the same back stack.
Let's call A the first activity in the back stack, and B the second activity in the back stack.
case 1: A is notified that it goes in the background when A was in the foreground and then B comes in the foreground (for any reason, like because it received an external intent).
case 2: A is notified that it goes in the background when A was in the foreground but another application was started in the foreground.
Question: How does my app differentiate between those 2 cases? Is there a way to know if the transition A in foreground -> A in background keeps the current task displayed on the screen?
Basically, I need to get an event when the Android task becomes visible or invisible.
If I understand you correctly, your Activity A would do something different if Activity B doesn't get activated after A was paused.
First of all, it's not a good idea to let an activity do something when it's not visible anymore. As we see in the Android lifecycle, it could get stopped:
I would put your background code into a service. This service gets notified whenever Activity A or B gets paused or resumed. There you could add a little timeout which has to pass till you start your logic.
If you do that, that would happen:
Case 1:
Activity A goes into background and sends a message in the onPause handler to your service. Service starts its timeout timer. Activity B gets started and sends a message in it's onResume handler to the service.
Now the services knows it's still the same activity and acts accordingly.
Case 2:
Activity A goes into background and sends the message. The service starts its timeout timer. It timeouts (I think 200ms would be enough) and now your service knows the task isn't active anymore and acts accordingly.
Use log or Toast in activity life cycle to display message
Keep a static flag in Activity B. set it on resume and unset it on pause.
Override onPostResume
#Override
protected void onPostResume() {
//Your code here
super.onPostResume();
}
Related
I am sending some data from my activity to a server. I keep it running in background using:
public void onBackPressed() {
moveTaskToBack (true);
}
But if the data is not being send for say about 10min because of some network problem. After recovering from n/w problem it doesnt continue to send.
Why is it so? Does the activity stops after sometime if it has nothing to do?
You can simply start a Service that will run in background and
send your data to server. If you call that in main thread of the activity it may hang you activity and could not process it because activity has a life cycle. It may end UP!
start a background service and perform all the operation in it. :)
Check out the documentation. This method just moves your activity to the back of the activity stack, it is still being paused, and so - eligible for finalization by the OS. Your activity is probably being destroyed.
If you want a certain process to keep running while your activity is paused, either use a service, like Raghunandan suggested, or start an AsyncTask if you need to update the UI after your data sending has completed.
As I understand it, an activity being destroyed is not equivalently to an activity being finished.
Finished
The activity is removed from the back stack.
It can be triggered by the program (e.g. by calling finish()), or by the user pressing the back key (which implicitly calls finish()).
Finishing an activity will destroy it.
Destroyed
The Android OS may destroy an invisible activity to recover memory. The activity will be recreated when the user navigates back to it.
The activity is destroyed and recreated when the user rotates the screen.
Reference: Recreating an Activity
So how do I finish a destroyed activity? The finish() method requires an Activity object, but if the activity is destroyed, I have no Activity object - I am not supposed to be holding a reference to a destroyed activity, am I?
Case study:
I have an activity a, which starts b, which in turn starts c (using Activity.startActivity()), so now the back stack is:
a → b → c
In c, the user fills out a form and tap the Submit button. A network request is made to a remote server using AsyncTask. After the task is completed, I show a toast and finish the activity by calling c.finish(). Perfect.
Now consider this scenario:
While the async task is in progress, the user switches to another app. Then, the Android OS decided to destroy all 3 activities (a, b, c) due to memory constraints. Later, the async task is completed. Now how do I finish c?
What I have tried:
Call c.finish():
Can't, because c is destroyed.
Call b.finishActivity():
Can't, because b is destroyed.
Use Context.startActivity() with FLAG_ACTIVITY_CLEAR_TOP so as to raise b to the top, thus finishing c:
// appContext is an application context, not an activity context (which I don't have)
Intent intent = new Intent(appContext, B.class); // B is b's class.
intent.setFlags(Intent.FLAG_ACTIVITY_CLEAR_TOP);
appContext.startActivity(intent);
Failed, appContext.startActivity() throws an exception:
android.util.AndroidRuntimeException: Calling startActivity() from outside of an Activity context requires the FLAG_ACTIVITY_NEW_TASK flag. Is this really what you want?
Edit: Clarification: I need to wait until the async task finishes and decide whether to finish c based on server's response.
android.util.AndroidRuntimeException: Calling startActivity() from
outside of an Activity context requires the FLAG_ACTIVITY_NEW_TASK
flag. Is this really what you want?
This exception used to occur when you are starting an activity from
the background thread or service. You need to pass
FLAG_ACTIVITY_NEW_TASK flag whenever you need the "launcher"
type of behavior.
Just add mIntent.addFlags(Intent.FLAG_ACTIVITY_NEW_TASK); to avoid this exception.
The way you are trying to kill the activity is not recommended, let the
android handle itself. There isn't any meaning to finish an activity
which is already destroyed.
Now, what you can do?
If you are facing problem in finishing activity when app is not in foreground, what you can do is to implement a security check which will finish the activity only when app is in foreground to go to back-stack activity or else just skip that step.
I think you are trying to kill the activity when app is in background. It seems a little bit difficult to do so, but you can make use of onUserLeaveHint to decide when app is going in the background in-order to finish the activity or you can finish the activity by adding finish(); in onStop(). Just make sure that asynctask's onPost() don't finish it again in-order to avoid the exception.
Have a look at android:clearTaskOnLaunch attribute and set it to true.
Google Doc says about this attribute is:
for example, that someone launches activity P from the home screen,
and from there goes to activity Q. The user next presses Home, and
then returns to activity P. Normally, the user would see activity Q,
since that is what they were last doing in P's task. However, if P set
this flag to "true", all of the activities on top of it (Q in this
case) were removed when the user pressed Home and the task went to the
background. So the user sees only P when returning to the task.
and i think this is the exact case which you want.
Hope this will give you some hint to achieve your desired task.
you can broadcast your action from the onPostExecute method in c and register a broadcast receiver to receive for that action in a and b. Then do finish in that receiver onRevice method
In c , AsyncTask,
void onPostExecute(Long result) {
----
Intent intent1 = new Intent("you custom action");
context.sendBroadcast(intent1);
}
In a and b
registerReceiver(new BroadcastReceiver() {
#Override
public void onReceive(Context context, Intent intent) {
finish();
}
},new IntentFilter("you custom action"));
Personally, I'd use the notification bar to notify the user of the status of his query.
This way, I'd avoid the entire issue of having an unfinished activity. And I'd only keep the activity unfinished only if the user had not clicked on the submit button yet.
Regarding android manual onDestroy() called exactly before activity is destroyed, so you can call finish in it (even you can stop your bg thread before killing the activity completly).
We can assume that if activity was killed we don't interested in bg thread either, and for example if bg thread is to download image or etc that needs to be completed - so you have to use service instead of asynctask.
Can't finish a destroyed activity directly, so just finish() it in its onCreate() (suggested by #Labeeb P). Here's how:
If the activity is already destroyed when trying to finish it, save a boolean flag somewhere instead.
if(activity != null)
{
// Activity object still valid, so finish() now.
activity.finish();
}
else
{
// Activity is destroyed, so save a flag.
is_activity_pending_finish = true;
}
If the flag needs to stay even if the app is destroyed, use persistent storage, e.g. SharedPreferences (suggested by #Labeeb P).
In the activity's onCreate(), check the flag and call finish().
#Override
protected void onCreate(Bundle savedInstanceState)
{
super.onCreate(savedInstanceState);
if(is_activity_pending_finish)
{
is_activity_pending_finish = false; // Clear the flag.
// This activity should have been finished, so finish it now.
finish();
return;
}
...
}
If there're multiple instances of the same Activity class, you may need something more than a boolean flag to identify the specific instance of activity to finish.
Calling finish() in onCreate() is actually a legimate operation, as it is mentioned in the doc:
... you might call finish() from within onCreate() to destroy the activity. In this case, the system immediately calls onDestroy() without calling any of the other lifecycle methods.
Other considerations:
It may not be a good idea to finish an activity while the app is in background, especially if it is the only activity. Make sure that you don't confuse the user.
For better user experience, if you finish an activity while the app is in background, you may want to inform the user. Consider using toasts (good for short notices) or notifications (good for long operations that the user may have forgotten)(suggested by #Stephan Branczyk and #dilix).
Of course, an activity being destroyed doesn't necessary mean that the app is in background (there might be another foreground activity). Still, the above solution (calling finish() in onCreate()) works.
When the system tries to destroy your Activity, it calls onSaveInstanceState. In here you can call finish(). That's it.
Warning: I've never tried this, so I don't know for sure if there are any issues with calling finish() from onSaveInstanceState. If you try this, please comment and let me know how it works out.
Sorry for answering this almost 10 years later.
In my understanding the premise of the question is wrong, mainly this part:
"While the async task is in progress, the user switches to another app. Then, the Android OS decided to destroy all 3 activities (a, b, c) due to memory constraints. Later, the async task is completed. Now how do I finish c?"
In my understanding if the operating system decides to destroy all three activities due to memory constraints, it won't destroy only them, but the whole process, and this should be including the AsyncTask in question. So, the async task won't be able to complete as well.
Resource: https://medium.com/androiddevelopers/who-lives-and-who-dies-process-priorities-on-android-cb151f39044f
mainly this line from the article: "Note that while we’ll talk about specific components (services, activities), Android only kills processes, not components."
In todays world, I guess that a WorkManager would be used for running work that needs to be guaranteed to run.
I have the following flow in my code:
Activity1 : startActivity(Activity2) --->
Activity2: startActivity(Activity3) --->
Activity3: startService(MyService) --->
MyService: startActivity(Activity4)
Each Activity above shows a single view and represents a step in a 4-step setup. The final Activity - Activity 4 - is started after some setup work is done inside MyService, which basically tells the user,
"The service has started, you can close the application by pressing Back or Home button"
When the user presses Back or Home, I want to destroy Activities 1-4 , and only have MyService running. Also, after stopping the Application as above, when the user navigates back to the Application via the menu and starts it, I'll be checking if MyService is already running. If it is already running, I don't want to show Activities 1-3, I want to show another Control Panel View (Another Activity), which says,
"Dude, the service is already running, do you want to Stop or Restart it?"
This view will have a Stop and Restart button, to do the appropriate tasks.
My Questions:
How do I stop Activities 1-4 from inside Activity 4 when Back or Home is pressed,safely? My thought was to add a static stopActivity() method to each Activity, and calling Activity[1-3].stopActivity() from onBackPressed() or onPause() of Activity4. Then inside each stopActivity(), I'll call finish(), thus ending each Activity. But is it safe and efficient to do it this way?
The flow I have illustrated above, is it the optimal way of doing things, or is there a cleaner way? I have BroadcastReceivers registered in these Activities, so I need to perform clean exits for each Activity, without leaked receivers, or worse, crashing the App or affect the User's phone due to unclean exit strategies.
Thanks for your suggestions.
You don't need to stop activities, Android will do it for you. Start your activities using intents with the flag FLAG_ACTIVITY_NO_HISTORY so they won't appear when the user presses back. Those activities will be stopped as soon as the user leaves them.
In the onStop method of each of your activities, write any code you want to deallocate memory if there is something you want to deallocate manually, although that wouldn't be necessary because Android will deallocate it for yourself when the device is short on memory. In those onStop methods unregister any BroadcastReceiverpreviously registered.
I have an Android app. I have a main activity, that has a button. When the button is clicked, another activity comes to the foreground. The thing is, I want to run a background thread that polls updates from the server. However, I want it to run only when the app is in foreground (either the main activity or the second one), and to stop polling when the user clicks the Home button or clicks the Back button till it's going back from the main activity.
But how do I know if the app is still in the foreground? I can catch the onPause of the main activity, but it's called also when I'm launching the second activity.
So how do I know when the app is in background?
Thanks
You should make a Service for the work you are doing in the background.
For stopping it when you click the Home or Back button, just make a listener for them and stop the Service when either one is pressed.
Seems easiest to me that each activity polls. Is it super important that it can poll when it is between the two activities? Otherwise you will have problems about knowing who is in front or not.
You can have a singleton with reference counting.
You main activity should add the first reference on it's onResume and from now, upon calling for every new activity (startActivity for example) you should add a reference.
Each activity should decrease the reference counting on its onPause.
Another option is to use services: Services
I have a Service which tracks the location of the user. Currently, the Service boots when the application starts and stops when the application terminates. Unfortunately, if users keep the application in the background, the Service never stops and drains battery.
I would like the Service to stop when my application is not in the foreground. I was hoping the Application class would let me Override onPause and onResume handlers, but it does not have them. Is there another way I can accomplish this?
I haven't tested this yet, but it looks like if you use Context#bindService() (instead of Context#startService()), the service should stop when no more activities are bound to it. (see Service lifecycle).
Then use onPause()/onResume() in each activity to bind/unbind from the service.
Alternatively, you could add a pair of methods on your service which tell it to start/stop listening for location updates and call it from each activity's onResume()/onPause(). The service would still be running, but the location updates wouldn't be draining the battery.
Reading all the above answers I would suggest Simply add a boolean global flag for each activity & put it in your onResume & onPause & also while launching an Activity Something like this
public void onPause()
{
super.onPause();
activity1IsResumed = true;
}
&same for onResume
& similarly when launching a new Activity
startActivityForResult(myintent ,0);
activity2IsResumed = true;
activity1IsResumed = false;
then in your Service simply check
if(activity1IsResumed || activity2IsResumed || activity3IsResumed)
{
//your logic
}
else
{
//another logic
//or dont run location tracker
}
& you are done!
You should override the onPause and onResume methods on your Activity. If you have multiple activities you may want to have a common base class for them and put the start/stop logic into the base class.
I have not tried this approach but I think you can override the home key of android device by using KeyEvent.KEYCODE_HOME and you can use stopService(Intent) to stop your service and when again application resumes, you can write startService(Intent) in the onResume() method of your Activity.
This way I think your service will only stop when user explicitly presses home button to take application in the background and not when he switches from one activity to another.
What I would suggest is overriding the onPause/onReume methods as others have said. Without knowing more about the flow of your application and interactions between Activities, I can't give much more information beyond guesswork.
If your Activities are persistent, however, my recommendation would be to utilize the Intents better when switching between Activities.
For instance, each Activity should have a boolean "transition" flag. So, when you move from one Activity to the next, you set up an Intent extra:
intent.putExtra("transition",true);
Followed in the receiving Activity by: (in onCreate)
intent.getBooleanExtra("transition",false);
This way, for each Activity that launches, you can know whether it has come from another Activity, or if it has been launched from a home screen launcher. Thus, if it gets a true transition, then onPause should NOT stop the service--that means you will be returning to the previous Activity after it returns. If it receives no "transition" extra, or a false transition, then you can safely assume there is no Activity underneath it waiting to take over for the current one.
On the first Activity, you will simply need to stop the service if you are switching to another Activity, which you should be able to figure out programmatically if one Activity is started from another.
It sounds like the real problem is how to only stop the service when you go to an activity that isn't one of your own? One way would be to in your onPause method to stop the activity. Do this for all your activities. Then override your startActivity method. And in here do a conditional test to confirm that you are purposefully navigating to one of your own. If your are set a flag to true.
Now go back to your on pause overridden method. And only stop your service if the flag is not equal to true. Set the flag to false.
All events that navigate away will close your service. Navigating to your own will leave it intact.
Do the overriding in a base class that all your activities extend.
Writeen in my andolroid. Will post ezaple later.
Try using the Bound Services technique to accomplish this.
Bound Services | Android Developers
You can use bound services in a way such that the service will stop when no activities are bound to it. This way, when the app is not in the foreground, the service will not be running. When the user brings the app back to the foreground, the Activity will bind to the service and the service will resume.
Create methods registerActivity() and unRegisterActivity() in your Application object and implement first method in all you acts onResume() and second in acts onPause().
First method add activity to List<Activity> instance in your app object, unRegisterActivity() checks size of list in every call if==0 stopService();.