I'm currently working on a project aimed to be ported both on Android and iOS.
Actually, it is a library written in C++, and we have a build system for the target platforms that is almost ready.
Despite the fact that it already works, it's quite complex and I was looking for something that can help in simplifying it.
I found the projects ios-cmake and android-cmake and thought that I could give them a try, but they look a bit abandoned and I'm not sure if it's worth it or there exists an alternative nowadays.
Did someone use them recently and can give me his feedback? It would be really appreciated.
Thank you.
Related
Can anyone suggest some good performance profiling tool for C/C++ code
that does not require recompiling/linking. I need for android platform.
Thanks.
After searching for a while i was not able to find descent one, so i solved this issue i.e. by taking timestamp as i enter a function and as i leave a function use them to find out time spent in function, it took little effort but i was able to find out the portion which is casuing bottleneck, you can give it a try. Not as good as something already cooked but it may help you identify problems!
I have found one: ARM DS-5 Community Edition (http://ds.arm.com/ds-5-community-edition/). It seems that this tool meets my requirement.
In my recently started internship (I'm studying computer science), I have to port a somewhat big existing Project to Android. It is a Visual C/C++ Project which in the end should run on Android using of course the NDK. The problem is that I don't know a thing about porting software, since this is not covered in my studies...
I had a few days to get to know the project I will be working with a little.
A few words about the complexity:
It is a Visual Studio solution which consists of 28 projects of which most are kind of big...
And now I need to develop a concept for porting it to Android, and this is why I'm writing this. I have absolutely no idea know where to start, also I don't know how to get to a concept for porting it. I tried searching online for some stuff or for some books covering this, but I found nothing.
Of course I know, that basically I have to remove everything that is Visual/Windows specific and replace it with appropriate Android/Linux functions or implement something new if there is nothing corresponding on Android.
But since this project is somewhat huge, I can't just try to compile it with the correct compiler and work through the error messages, this will lead to nowhere, I guess...
So now my actual question:
Is anybody experienced about this or something similar and can give some tips how to start with it? As I said, I first need a concept. Something more general about how to start and deal with porting a software project of this size is also very welcome, since I don't know nothing about it...
I think that you're approaching the whole matter in the wrong way. There are several tools that will allow you to compile C# and visual C++ and other visual languages from their respected IDEs to the android platform. For example there is mono for android . Mono is a plugin for visual studio which helps you create android projects using visual studio and .net technologies. I think you should focus your research on tools like this because changing all of the code manually is nearly impossible and too time consuming. Here is a page that will help you get started with mono for android. Good luck.
See this answer Android NDK with Visual Studio.
Personally I don't use this, but It seems to be a nice solution to your problem.
Like you, in the past, we had to port a big Visual C++ library project to Android, we proceeded in this way:
Try to compile the main library interface (by creating the relative Android.mk)
By using linking errors, you should guess other projects to be compiled and create the mks for them
Cycle until you have no more linking errors.
You didn't tell about the source code size of the project (how many thousands of lines of source code).
If the code size is big enough (e.g. at least 100 KLOC), you could consider customizing the GCC compiler (assuming a recent 4.6 or 4.7 version), perhaps using MELT (a high level domain specific language to extend GCC), or painfully coding in C a GCC plugin. This GCC customizing approach is worthwhile only for large code bases (you'll need several days to master GCC internals).
On the other hand, many well designed applications may have packaged their operating system functions inside a well defined interface and library. You might consider porting your application to Qt or some other cross-platform library.
We need more details about your project to help you more.
Hi there Im new to mobile application development. I had developed Android apps using Java and is just starting to get the hang of Cocoa Touch and Objective C. Now I am curious on mobile web application development to create cross platform/device applications which would at least run on Android and iOS(Apple devices: iphone, ipad). I tried Titanium and developing applications with this framework seems very promising. Although it is very powerful, popular, mature, documented and very easy to learn I had doubts investing time and to commit on using this framework for my projects after reading this blog which many Titanium users seems to agree with Why you should stay away from appcelerators titanium.
It seems that release v1.6 sdk and v1.7 sdk have the issue which they describe, the negative comments stopped right after the v1.8 sdk release was out.
My question is, is Titanium v1.8 sdk free from the memory starvation issue and other issues which were discussed on the blog post?
Would you personally recommend this for production use? And by the way I am using the 1.0.7.201112152014 Titanium build does this use the 1.8 sdk? Thanks in advance.
Take a close look at the progress of comments. It starts from people agreeing with him, and in the end everyone disagrees.
You can select the SDK you wish in the tiapp.xml editor, which is embedded in Titanium Studio. You should indeed use 1.8.x
The platform isn't, and probably never will be, memory issue free. But it also depends on how you build your app.
Stay away as much as you can from includes. And also stay away from creating a window/view/etc. with a file as url in it, this causes most memory issues because it's in a different space.
If you code well, you can use it perfectly without any issues.
Blog post author here. I don't fully agree with Topener - go ahead and read the comments yourself, it's just not true that "in the end everyone disagrees".
For what's worth: my experience is related to version 1.6.2. I've talked to people working with trunk and they told me that the memory issues are far from being resolved.
The only approach that seems to work is, as mentioned in the comments, the Tweetanium approach. But beware, that's not "if you code well". It's "if you code the way Titanium likes". If you take a look at Tweetanium (I suggest you to do it no matter what you decide to do in the end) you'll see that it has a very specific way to deal with architecture. If you follow that path, you should be good. If you think that the way Tweetanium is structured is good for you application, go for it. Be wary though, because (at least in what I consider to be complex) Tweetanium is not very complex, and with growing complexity I found that their approach is difficult to maintain. Again, evaluate for yourself.
Then there's the Android issue. Android support is far from optimal - Wunderlist decided to rewrite their Android version in native, I myself have had huge problems in making anything even remotely complex in iOS working decently on Android. If you need to support only iOS it's alright but, if that's the case, I don't see why you shouldn't write the app directly in Objective-C... considering also the (unavoidable) delay/mismatch between the Titanium and the iOS SDK.
Just my 2c. I suggest you not to take the decision lightly - it costed us a lot.
Is "AndroidAnnotations" reliable? I've searched it but couldn't find many articles on it(reviews or tutorials).
I've been considering using this library in my project which already has quite lots of users. Before adopting it, I need a good reputation on it. So my concerns mainly are,
Are there famous products using this library?
Can I say it's stable enough to adopt it for my big project?
Will it be maintained well? (bug fixes, etc)
Thanks in advance.
I am the lead developer of AndroidAnnotations. Let's answer your questions:
Can you rely on AndroidAnnotations?
I think so. AndroidAnnotations is a compile time framework which generates code. The generated code is readable java code, which means that if you need to understand what happens, you can. No magic happening at runtime => you are in control.
We try to maintain a list of external articles / tutorials here.
Are there famous products using this library?
Let's be honest: I don't know. Matthias Kaeppler from Qype talked about AndroidAnnotations at DroidCon London 2011. The frontpage lists the applications that we know for sure are using it. I know there are way more people using it because they ask for enhancements and report bugs, but they usually don't let us know when they publish an app. And of course, the idea of "writing clean and maintainable Android code" is not yet very common in the Android community.
Can I say it's stable enough to adopt it for my big project?
We are using it in our own apps, and we find it perfectly stable. So I would answer yes, but I think you should just try it :-) . Download the 2.2 RC2 (will be released stable soon), follow the instructions and see for yourself. You can do progressive enhancement, and start enhancing only one or two activities. See how it fits you, and let us know if anything goes wrong. And if you do release an app with AndroidAnnotations on the Android market, please let us know, we'll update the front page.
Will AndroidAnnotations be maintained?
Yes, it will. Although it started as a personal project, AndroidAnnotations is now sponsored by a company, eBusiness Information. This company employs people (including me) to work on AndroidAnnotations, with the aim of making it a major Open Source Android framework.
As you can see here and there, we are adding a lot of new features for the 2.2 release. And you won't find a lot of open Defects in the issues, because we concentrate on fixing any bug before adding new features.
The dream is to run Grim fandango on my android,
And i stumbled onto 'residual' (http://residual.sourceforge.net/ it's a c++ application) and someone who made it to run on his nokia n900 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TO9a5nTMHYI).
So for the question, would this be possible for android? My initial thought was the support debian and ubuntu and my android is faster then the n900, why not?
So before i spend days/weeks learning and getting it to work on my android,
I thought it might be a good idea to ask people who actually know about these things if its even possible.
And maybe how much work it really would be, in my head it's currently only:
make allot of Android.mk's
try to compile and fix errors still it works.
Which (if i don't get to many errors) doesn't sound to hard.
Any thoughts are welcome,
Thanks for reading!
I'd say your goal is totally feasible.
Residual seems to rely on standard C++ libraries, plus OpenGL and SDL. For the latter, there are actually several SDL Android ports out there you can take advantage of.
Somebody familiar with Android and the NDK could probably get Residual to a somewhat playable state in a few days (a proper port would take much longer ofc). If you're new to the platform however, you should be prepared to spend several weeks learning the basics of native application development in Android before tackling the project.