Firebase database keep secured from apk decompile and use [duplicate] - android
The Firebase Web-App guide states I should put the given apiKey in my Html to initialize Firebase:
// TODO: Replace with your project's customized code snippet
<script src="https://www.gstatic.com/firebasejs/3.0.2/firebase.js"></script>
<script>
// Initialize Firebase
var config = {
apiKey: '<your-api-key>',
authDomain: '<your-auth-domain>',
databaseURL: '<your-database-url>',
storageBucket: '<your-storage-bucket>'
};
firebase.initializeApp(config);
</script>
By doing so, the apiKey is exposed to every visitor.
What is the purpose of that key and is it really meant to be public?
The apiKey in this configuration snippet just identifies your Firebase project on the Google servers. It is not a security risk for someone to know it. In fact, it is necessary for them to know it, in order for them to interact with your Firebase project. This same configuration data is also included in every iOS and Android app that uses Firebase as its backend.
In that sense it is very similar to the database URL that identifies the back-end database associated with your project in the same snippet: https://<app-id>.firebaseio.com. See this question on why this is not a security risk: How to restrict Firebase data modification?, including the use of Firebase's server side security rules to ensure only authorized users can access the backend services.
If you want to learn how to secure all data access to your Firebase backend services is authorized, read up on the documentation on Firebase security rules. These rules control access to file storage and database access, and are enforced on the Firebase servers. So no matter if it's your code, or somebody else's code that uses you configuration data, it can only do what the security rules allow it to do.
For another explanation of what Firebase uses these values for, and for which of them you can set quotas, see the Firebase documentation on using and managing API keys.
If you'd like to reduce the risk of committing this configuration data to version control, consider using the SDK auto-configuration of Firebase Hosting. While the keys will still end up in the browser in the same format, they won't be hard-coded into your code anymore with that.
Update (May 2021): Thanks to the new feature called Firebase App Check, it is now actually possible to limit access to the backend services in your Firebase project to only those coming from iOS, Android and Web apps that are registered in that specific project.
You'll typically want to combine this with the user authentication based security described above, so that you have another shield against abusive users that do use your app.
By combining App Check with security rules you have both broad protection against abuse, and fine gained control over what data each user can access, while still allowing direct access to the database from your client-side application code.
Building on the answers of prufrofro and Frank van Puffelen here, I put together this setup that doesn't prevent scraping, but can make it slightly harder to use your API key.
Warning: To get your data, even with this method, one can for example simply open the JS console in Chrome and type:
firebase.database().ref("/get/all/the/data").once("value", function (data) {
console.log(data.val());
});
Only the database security rules can protect your data.
Nevertheless, I restricted my production API key use to my domain name like this:
https://console.developers.google.com/apis
Select your Firebase project
Credentials
Under API keys, pick your Browser key. It should look like this: "Browser key (auto created by Google Service)"
In "Accept requests from these
HTTP referrers (web sites)", add the URL of your app (exemple: projectname.firebaseapp.com/* )
Now the app will only work on this specific domain name. So I created another API Key that will be private for localhost developement.
Click Create credentials > API Key
By default, as mentioned by Emmanuel Campos, Firebase only whitelists localhost and your Firebase hosting domain.
In order to make sure I don't publish the wrong API key by mistake, I use one of the following methods to automatically use the more restricted one in production.
Setup for Create-React-App
In /env.development:
REACT_APP_API_KEY=###dev-key###
In /env.production:
REACT_APP_API_KEY=###public-key###
In /src/index.js
const firebaseConfig = {
apiKey: process.env.REACT_APP_API_KEY,
// ...
};
I am not convinced to expose security/config keys to client. I would not call it secure, not because some one can steal all private information from first day, because someone can make excessive request, and drain your quota and make you owe to Google a lot of money.
You need to think about many concepts from restricting people not to access where they are not supposed to be, DOS attacks etc.
I would more prefer the client first will hit to your web server, there you put what ever first hand firewall, captcha , cloudflare, custom security in between the client and server, or between server and firebase and you are good to go. At least you can first stop suspect activity before it reaches to firebase. You will have much more flexibility.
I only see one good usage scenario for using client based config for internal usages. For example, you have internal domain, and you are pretty sure outsiders cannot access there, so you can setup environment like browser -> firebase type.
The API key exposure creates a vulnerability when user/password sign up is enabled. There is an open API endpoint that takes the API key and allows anyone to create a new user account. They then can use this new account to log in to your Firebase Auth protected app or use the SDK to auth with user/pass and run queries.
I've reported this to Google but they say it's working as intended.
If you can't disable user/password accounts you should do the following:
Create a cloud function to auto disable new users onCreate and create a new DB entry to manage their access.
Ex: MyUsers/{userId}/Access: 0
exports.addUser = functions.auth.user().onCreate(onAddUser);
exports.deleteUser = functions.auth.user().onDelete(onDeleteUser);
Update your rules to only allow reads for users with access > 1.
On the off chance the listener function doesn't disable the account fast enough then the read rules will prevent them from reading any data.
I believe once database rules are written accurately, it will be enough to protect your data. Moreover, there are guidelines that one can follow to structure your database accordingly. For example, making a UID node under users, and putting all under information under it. After that, you will need to implement a simple database rule as below
"rules": {
"users": {
"$uid": {
".read": "auth != null && auth.uid == $uid",
".write": "auth != null && auth.uid == $uid"
}
}
}
}
No other user will be able to read other users' data, moreover, domain policy will restrict requests coming from other domains.
One can read more about it on
Firebase Security rules
While the original question was answered (that the api key can be exposed - the protection of the data must be set from the DB rulles), I was also looking for a solution to restrict the access to specific parts of the DB.
So after reading this and some personal research about the possibilities, I came up with a slightly different approach to restrict data usage for unauthorised users:
I save my users in my DB too, under the same uid (and save the profile data in there). So i just set the db rules like this:
".read": "auth != null && root.child('/userdata/'+auth.uid+'/userRole').exists()",
".write": "auth != null && root.child('/userdata/'+auth.uid+'/userRole').exists()"
This way only a previous saved user can add new users in the DB so there is no way anyone without an account can do operations on DB.
Also adding new users is posible only if the user has a special role and edit only by admin or by that user itself (something like this):
"userdata": {
"$userId": {
".write": "$userId === auth.uid || root.child('/userdata/'+auth.uid+'/userRole').val() === 'superadmin'",
...
EXPOSURE OF API KEYS ISN'T A SECURITY RISK BUT ANYONE CAN PUT YOUR CREDENTIALS ON THEIR SITE.
Open api keys leads to attacks that can use a lot resources at firebase that will definitely cost your hard money.
You can always restrict you firebase project keys to domains / IP's.
https://console.cloud.google.com/apis/credentials/key
select your project Id and key and restrict it to Your Android/iOs/web App.
It is oky to include them, and special care is required only for Firebase ML or when using Firebase Authentication
API keys for Firebase are different from typical API keys:
Unlike how API keys are typically used, API keys for Firebase services are not used to control access to backend resources; that can only be done with Firebase Security Rules. Usually, you need to fastidiously guard API keys (for example, by using a vault service or setting the keys as environment variables); however, API keys for Firebase services are ok to include in code or checked-in config files.
Although API keys for Firebase services are safe to include in code, there are a few specific cases when you should enforce limits for your API key; for example, if you're using Firebase ML or using Firebase Authentication with the email/password sign-in method. Learn more about these cases later on this page.
For more informations, check the offical docs
I am making a blog website on github pages. I got an idea to embbed comments in the end of every blog page. I understand how firebase get and gives you data.
I have tested many times with project and even using console. I am totally disagree the saying vlit is vulnerable.
Believe me there is no issue of showing your api key publically if you have followed privacy steps recommend by firebase.
Go to https://console.developers.google.com/apis
and perfrom a security steup.
You should not expose this info. in public, specially api keys.
It may lead to a privacy leak.
Before making the website public you should hide it. You can do it in 2 or more ways
Complex coding/hiding
Simply put firebase SDK codes at bottom of your website or app thus firebase automatically does all works. you don't need to put API keys anywhere
Related
Firebase - Predefined User list & Phone Number Authentication
I am working on one the Android APP & want to integrate it with the Firebase & it's Realtime Database. I have a list of 1000 users(Excel) with details like EmpId, EmpName, Team, Mobile Number, etc. I want to restrict my APP only to the users from this list & also want to authenticate them using the mobile number present in the list against there name. Can I use Firebase Auth for the above requirement & if yes, how to do that? If with FireBase Auth, this is not possible what is the alternative solution? Please help.
Firebase Authentication only allows the users to identify themselves. What you're describing is limiting what users are allowed to use your app, which is known as authorization, and Firebase Authentication doesn't handle that. Luckily you tagged with firebase-realtime-database too, and authorization is definitely built into that. What I'd usually do is create a top-level node in the database that contains the UID of users that are allowed to use the app: "allowedUsers": { "uidOfUser1": true, "uidOfUser2": true ... } Then in other security rules you'll check if the user's UID is in this list before allowing them access to data, with something like: { "rules": { "employees": { ".read": "root.child('allowedUsers').child(auth.uid).exists()", "$uid": { ".read": "auth.uid === $uid && root.child('allowedUsers').child(auth.uid).exists()" } } } } With these rules: Allowed users that are signed in can read all employee data. But they can only modify their own employee data. Of course you'll want to modify these rules to fit your own requirements, but hopefully this allows you to get started. A few things to keep in mind: The UID is only created once the users sign up in Firebase Authentication. This means you may have to map from the email addresses you have to the corresponding UIDs. You can either do this by precreating all users, do it in batches, or use a Cloud Function that triggers on user creation to add the known users to the allowedUsers list. Alternative you can store the list of email addresses in the database. Just keep in mind that somebody could sign in with somebody else's email address, unless you require email address verification. Oh, and you can't store the email address as a key in the database as-is, since . characters are not allowed, so you'll have to do some form of encoding on that. Also see: How do I lock down Firebase Database to any user from a specific (email) domain? (also shows how to check for email verification) Restrict Firebase users by email (shows using encoded email addresses) firebase realtime db security rule to allow specific users How to disable Signup in Firebase 3.x Firebase - Prevent user authentication
I know it's late but for anyone who may be referencing this question, my recommendation is blocking functions. You essentially create a Firebase Cloud Function that can accept or deny requests to make an account. Here's what it could look like: const functions = require('firebase-functions'); exports.beforeCreate = functions.auth.user().beforeCreate((user, context) => { var allowedUsers = ['johndoe#stackoverflow.com']; // if they are not in the list, they cannot make an account // throwing this error will prevent account creation if(allowUsers.indexOf(user.email) == -1) throw new functions.auth.HttpsError('permission-denied'); }); This way is better in my opinion because the security rules doesn't have to reference the database. Instead, the security rules can allow requests from any authenticated user, because the only authenticated users are ones allowed by this function.
How to secure firebase google-services.json file while reverse engineering [duplicate]
The Firebase Web-App guide states I should put the given apiKey in my Html to initialize Firebase: // TODO: Replace with your project's customized code snippet <script src="https://www.gstatic.com/firebasejs/3.0.2/firebase.js"></script> <script> // Initialize Firebase var config = { apiKey: '<your-api-key>', authDomain: '<your-auth-domain>', databaseURL: '<your-database-url>', storageBucket: '<your-storage-bucket>' }; firebase.initializeApp(config); </script> By doing so, the apiKey is exposed to every visitor. What is the purpose of that key and is it really meant to be public?
The apiKey in this configuration snippet just identifies your Firebase project on the Google servers. It is not a security risk for someone to know it. In fact, it is necessary for them to know it, in order for them to interact with your Firebase project. This same configuration data is also included in every iOS and Android app that uses Firebase as its backend. In that sense it is very similar to the database URL that identifies the back-end database associated with your project in the same snippet: https://<app-id>.firebaseio.com. See this question on why this is not a security risk: How to restrict Firebase data modification?, including the use of Firebase's server side security rules to ensure only authorized users can access the backend services. If you want to learn how to secure all data access to your Firebase backend services is authorized, read up on the documentation on Firebase security rules. These rules control access to file storage and database access, and are enforced on the Firebase servers. So no matter if it's your code, or somebody else's code that uses you configuration data, it can only do what the security rules allow it to do. For another explanation of what Firebase uses these values for, and for which of them you can set quotas, see the Firebase documentation on using and managing API keys. If you'd like to reduce the risk of committing this configuration data to version control, consider using the SDK auto-configuration of Firebase Hosting. While the keys will still end up in the browser in the same format, they won't be hard-coded into your code anymore with that. Update (May 2021): Thanks to the new feature called Firebase App Check, it is now actually possible to limit access to the backend services in your Firebase project to only those coming from iOS, Android and Web apps that are registered in that specific project. You'll typically want to combine this with the user authentication based security described above, so that you have another shield against abusive users that do use your app. By combining App Check with security rules you have both broad protection against abuse, and fine gained control over what data each user can access, while still allowing direct access to the database from your client-side application code.
Building on the answers of prufrofro and Frank van Puffelen here, I put together this setup that doesn't prevent scraping, but can make it slightly harder to use your API key. Warning: To get your data, even with this method, one can for example simply open the JS console in Chrome and type: firebase.database().ref("/get/all/the/data").once("value", function (data) { console.log(data.val()); }); Only the database security rules can protect your data. Nevertheless, I restricted my production API key use to my domain name like this: https://console.developers.google.com/apis Select your Firebase project Credentials Under API keys, pick your Browser key. It should look like this: "Browser key (auto created by Google Service)" In "Accept requests from these HTTP referrers (web sites)", add the URL of your app (exemple: projectname.firebaseapp.com/* ) Now the app will only work on this specific domain name. So I created another API Key that will be private for localhost developement. Click Create credentials > API Key By default, as mentioned by Emmanuel Campos, Firebase only whitelists localhost and your Firebase hosting domain. In order to make sure I don't publish the wrong API key by mistake, I use one of the following methods to automatically use the more restricted one in production. Setup for Create-React-App In /env.development: REACT_APP_API_KEY=###dev-key### In /env.production: REACT_APP_API_KEY=###public-key### In /src/index.js const firebaseConfig = { apiKey: process.env.REACT_APP_API_KEY, // ... };
I am not convinced to expose security/config keys to client. I would not call it secure, not because some one can steal all private information from first day, because someone can make excessive request, and drain your quota and make you owe to Google a lot of money. You need to think about many concepts from restricting people not to access where they are not supposed to be, DOS attacks etc. I would more prefer the client first will hit to your web server, there you put what ever first hand firewall, captcha , cloudflare, custom security in between the client and server, or between server and firebase and you are good to go. At least you can first stop suspect activity before it reaches to firebase. You will have much more flexibility. I only see one good usage scenario for using client based config for internal usages. For example, you have internal domain, and you are pretty sure outsiders cannot access there, so you can setup environment like browser -> firebase type.
The API key exposure creates a vulnerability when user/password sign up is enabled. There is an open API endpoint that takes the API key and allows anyone to create a new user account. They then can use this new account to log in to your Firebase Auth protected app or use the SDK to auth with user/pass and run queries. I've reported this to Google but they say it's working as intended. If you can't disable user/password accounts you should do the following: Create a cloud function to auto disable new users onCreate and create a new DB entry to manage their access. Ex: MyUsers/{userId}/Access: 0 exports.addUser = functions.auth.user().onCreate(onAddUser); exports.deleteUser = functions.auth.user().onDelete(onDeleteUser); Update your rules to only allow reads for users with access > 1. On the off chance the listener function doesn't disable the account fast enough then the read rules will prevent them from reading any data.
I believe once database rules are written accurately, it will be enough to protect your data. Moreover, there are guidelines that one can follow to structure your database accordingly. For example, making a UID node under users, and putting all under information under it. After that, you will need to implement a simple database rule as below "rules": { "users": { "$uid": { ".read": "auth != null && auth.uid == $uid", ".write": "auth != null && auth.uid == $uid" } } } } No other user will be able to read other users' data, moreover, domain policy will restrict requests coming from other domains. One can read more about it on Firebase Security rules
While the original question was answered (that the api key can be exposed - the protection of the data must be set from the DB rulles), I was also looking for a solution to restrict the access to specific parts of the DB. So after reading this and some personal research about the possibilities, I came up with a slightly different approach to restrict data usage for unauthorised users: I save my users in my DB too, under the same uid (and save the profile data in there). So i just set the db rules like this: ".read": "auth != null && root.child('/userdata/'+auth.uid+'/userRole').exists()", ".write": "auth != null && root.child('/userdata/'+auth.uid+'/userRole').exists()" This way only a previous saved user can add new users in the DB so there is no way anyone without an account can do operations on DB. Also adding new users is posible only if the user has a special role and edit only by admin or by that user itself (something like this): "userdata": { "$userId": { ".write": "$userId === auth.uid || root.child('/userdata/'+auth.uid+'/userRole').val() === 'superadmin'", ...
EXPOSURE OF API KEYS ISN'T A SECURITY RISK BUT ANYONE CAN PUT YOUR CREDENTIALS ON THEIR SITE. Open api keys leads to attacks that can use a lot resources at firebase that will definitely cost your hard money. You can always restrict you firebase project keys to domains / IP's. https://console.cloud.google.com/apis/credentials/key select your project Id and key and restrict it to Your Android/iOs/web App.
It is oky to include them, and special care is required only for Firebase ML or when using Firebase Authentication API keys for Firebase are different from typical API keys: Unlike how API keys are typically used, API keys for Firebase services are not used to control access to backend resources; that can only be done with Firebase Security Rules. Usually, you need to fastidiously guard API keys (for example, by using a vault service or setting the keys as environment variables); however, API keys for Firebase services are ok to include in code or checked-in config files. Although API keys for Firebase services are safe to include in code, there are a few specific cases when you should enforce limits for your API key; for example, if you're using Firebase ML or using Firebase Authentication with the email/password sign-in method. Learn more about these cases later on this page. For more informations, check the offical docs
I am making a blog website on github pages. I got an idea to embbed comments in the end of every blog page. I understand how firebase get and gives you data. I have tested many times with project and even using console. I am totally disagree the saying vlit is vulnerable. Believe me there is no issue of showing your api key publically if you have followed privacy steps recommend by firebase. Go to https://console.developers.google.com/apis and perfrom a security steup.
You should not expose this info. in public, specially api keys. It may lead to a privacy leak. Before making the website public you should hide it. You can do it in 2 or more ways Complex coding/hiding Simply put firebase SDK codes at bottom of your website or app thus firebase automatically does all works. you don't need to put API keys anywhere
Authenticated user misusing firebase databse to increase points
I have made an android app and using Firebase realtime database as backend. In the app i have some In-App purchase products too. These products are abount buying points(such as 150 points, 1000 points etc.). The problem is right now i am seeing that some users increasing huge amount of points to their profile. For the sake of relatime view of firebase database i am seeing that their points increasing like 50k, 100k. But i don't have any In-App purchase product with this huge amount. I am tired of disabling their account & can't find a way to prevent it. I know some app that are used to hack points/coins like Freedom APK and some other. But these apps require the device to be rooted. So on App launch i checked whether the device is rooted or not. Right now rooted device are not allowed to use my app. Still they are hacking points. I am using following database rules { "rules": { "Users": { "$userID": { ".write": "auth != null", ".read": "auth != null" } } } } And database structure is: Users- uId: userEmail userName userPoints The workflow of valid point increase is: User buy a In-App product --> User points increase as per the product value User watch a rewarded video ad --> User points increase by +8 I want to prevent these hackers to generating points.
I am no expert with android and realtime database but the problem is that the user have write access to the database. I do not know how but they somehow can manipulate the data which is sent to your database. You need to validate the data before it is written to your database. You could do some validation with security rules but in my opinion the easiest way is to use callable cloud functions to validate your data and revoke the write access to your database. If the user buys points they should call a cloud function which verifies if the data is valid. If the data is valid the cloud function updates the database. This way the user can not manipulate their points. For my online shop i use cloud functions to verify the cart content on checkout and the users can not directly write to the database. You should do something similar. Edit: Here you could find an introduction to cloud functions. https://firebase.google.com/docs/functions And here you could find some information about callable cloud function which i recommend. With a callable function you can invoke the backend function directly from your code without an API call. https://firebase.google.com/docs/functions/callable
Firebase security rules and prevention of unwanted application access [duplicate]
How do I prevent other users from accessing my Realtime Database via my Firebase URL? What must I do to secure it to only my domain?
First of all, understand that you cannot secure any URL on the internet according to the origin domain--malicious users can simply lie. Securing the origin domains is only useful in preventing cross-site spoofing attacks (where a malicious source pretends to be your site and dupes your users into logging in on their behalf). The good news is that users are already prevented from authenticating from unauthorized domains from the start. You can set your authorized domains in Forge: type your Firebase url into a browser (e.g. https://INSTANCE.firebaseio.com/) log in click on the Auth tab add your domain to the list of Authorized Requests Origins select a "provider" you want to use and configure accordingly Now to secure your data, you will go to the security tab and add security rules. A good starting point is as follows: { "rules": { // only authenticated users can read or write to my Firebase ".read": "auth !== null", ".write": "auth !== null" } } Security rules are a big topic. You will want to get up to speed by reading the overview and watching this video
Setup security Rules, source to learn : https://firebase.google.com/docs/rules Use Emulators (It will make keys not easy to visible by beginner programmers) , source : https://firebase.google.com/docs/rules/emulator-setup Cloud Functions (It will hide the names of Collections and Docs) , https://firebase.google.com/docs/functions Limit the API keys to specific website/s(It will make peoples unable to access your website/app from outside) if someone knows more methods, please tell, no one can be perfect.
Add some kind of auth to Firebase realtime database without using Firebase Auth [duplicate]
How do I prevent other users from accessing my Realtime Database via my Firebase URL? What must I do to secure it to only my domain?
First of all, understand that you cannot secure any URL on the internet according to the origin domain--malicious users can simply lie. Securing the origin domains is only useful in preventing cross-site spoofing attacks (where a malicious source pretends to be your site and dupes your users into logging in on their behalf). The good news is that users are already prevented from authenticating from unauthorized domains from the start. You can set your authorized domains in Forge: type your Firebase url into a browser (e.g. https://INSTANCE.firebaseio.com/) log in click on the Auth tab add your domain to the list of Authorized Requests Origins select a "provider" you want to use and configure accordingly Now to secure your data, you will go to the security tab and add security rules. A good starting point is as follows: { "rules": { // only authenticated users can read or write to my Firebase ".read": "auth !== null", ".write": "auth !== null" } } Security rules are a big topic. You will want to get up to speed by reading the overview and watching this video
Setup security Rules, source to learn : https://firebase.google.com/docs/rules Use Emulators (It will make keys not easy to visible by beginner programmers) , source : https://firebase.google.com/docs/rules/emulator-setup Cloud Functions (It will hide the names of Collections and Docs) , https://firebase.google.com/docs/functions Limit the API keys to specific website/s(It will make peoples unable to access your website/app from outside) if someone knows more methods, please tell, no one can be perfect.